Rare Unseen Pictures Which Relate To Tipperary

War does not determine who is right – only who is left.” Quote attributed to Bertrand Russell.

It was on 21st January 1919 that two Irish born Roman Catholic RIC constables, James Alec McDonnell and Patrick O’Connell, were escorting a horse drawn cart containing gelignite from the Tipperary town Military Barracks to the local Soloheadbeg Quarry, a distance of 7.7km or just 10 minutes modern day driving time apart. The driver of the cart was James Godfrey, accompanied by Patrick Flynn, the latter a County Council employee.

Constable McDonnell, a native of Belmullet, Co. Mayo and father of seven children, together with comrade Constable O’Connell, latter a native of Coachford, County Cork and unmarried, were both guarding this cargo of explosives.

James McDonnell & Anastasia (Doyle) (Sepia Pic) - His son Christopher McDonnell & Bridget (McGrath) (Black & White Pic) Pictures courtesy Sweeney Family

James McDonnell & Anastasia (Doyle) (Sepia Pic) – His son Christopher McDonnell & Bridget (McGrath) (Black & White Pic)
Pictures come courtesy of the Sweeney family.

History records that possibly up to eight armed and masked men, members of the then Irish Volunteers from the South Tipperary Brigade, which included their leader Séamus Robinson, Sean Tracy, Dan Breen, Sean Hogan, Tadgh Crowe, Patrick Dwyer, Michael Ryan, and Patrick McCormack opened fire on the Constables, killing both men. Volunteer GHQ had not sanctioned this ambush.

The driver and County Council worker were left unharmed. In the pocket of Constable McDonnell’s uniform were 30 electric detonators which remained undiscovered by their assailants. Hogan with Treacy and Breen drove the cart together with the explosives away from the scene. Eye witnesses later saw the cart being driven at high speed in the direction of Dundrum village, County Tipperary, and indeed the horse and cart minus its contents were later found abandoned at Allen Creamery near Dundrum, by the District Inspector of Clonmel Poer O’Shee.

The picture directly above shows; Back Row: - Bonnie, Alden & Doug Rohrer from Texas. Front Row:- Aileen Sweeneyher husband Roy With their Children Neil Eoin & Blaine with museum guide Stewart Willoughby.

The picture directly above shows; Back Row: – Bonnie, Alden & Doug Rohrer from Texas. Front Row:- Aileen Sweeney (Left), her husband Roy (Right), with their children Neil, Eoin & Blaine, &  St Mary’s Famine Museum, Thurles, guide Stewart Willoughby.

A major historic event took place in St Mary’s Famine Museum in June of this year 2013, which truly should have demanded a far wider audience. It was the visit by Mrs Aileen Sweeney, latter the great granddaughter of James Alec McDonnell, the first victim of the War of Independence against England, together with her immediate family.  Picture above shows McDonnell’s great, great grandson holding the gun, a Colt 45, which killed his great, great grandfather and possible the gun which fired the first shot which began the War of Independence, eventually leading to brother fighting brother, in an ensuing civil war.

Condemnation for these killings would be swift and come from every quarter, even from some well known local republicans and local clergy. Dan Breen claimed the constables attacked first, but a body of opinion state that this was unlikely given the odds against them. Dan Breen claims in his book “My fight for Irish Freedom” that the constables raised their rifles in preparation for a fight and that they were forced to retaliate. However Dan Breen would however later recall:

“We took the action deliberately, having thought over the matter and talked it over between us. Treacy had stated to me that the only way of starting a war was to kill someone, and we wanted to start a war, so we intended to kill some of the police whom we looked upon as the foremost and most important branch of the enemy forces … The only regret that we had following the ambush was that there were only two policemen in it, instead of the six we had expected..”

The real true facts of this incident now lie forever buried.

Thanks however to continued communications with the Sweeney family we have further information to share with our Thurles.Info readers. Following the ambush, and some time later, James McDonnell’s son Christopher wrote to a local newspaper, which in turn published the following statement:-

I have read many versions in your paper of the “Soloheadbeg Murder,” and the many people who profess such accurate knowledge of what took place.  I cannot keep silent any longer.  As a son of one of the policeman killed I can give the true story. 

My father, Constable (James) McDonnell, was an old man of 65 years and was due to retire on pension in a week’s time.  He had a large family, one (myself) a cripple on crutches. His wife was paralysed for years and was confined to a wheelchair. That day he was called upon, as a usual routine duty, to guard a cart of gelignite and, as he suffered from corns, sat up on the cart for relief. 

Suddenly they were halted by Dan Breen and his companions and shot immediately. When my father’s body was taken in we found he was shot in the back.  What a glorious act to go down in history!  My father was a good man and loved and respected by all the people there.  Many times I saw him bring farmers, with too much drink taken on fair and market days, leading their horses and cars outside the town so as to avoid others arresting them. 

Well, Dan Breen is now gone to meet the same God my father did, and as a Christian and a Catholic, I will not judge him.  I leave it to God, although he left us with broken hearts and home. So let us hear less of this hero worship.”  (Christy McDonnell, Belmullet.)

While most of us hold the theory that there are two sides to every issue; one side being right and the other being wrong, somewhere hidden in the centre of conflict can be located some aspect of evil. For me personally, I have long ago learned that there are inevitably three sides to every story. There is yours, theirs and the incontrovertible truth.


11 comments to Rare Unseen Pictures Which Relate To Tipperary

  • Cathy McDonnell McQueen

    Like Aileen Sweeney, I too am the great granddaughter of James McDonnell. I am the granddaughter of Michael Alphonsus McDonnell, James and Anastasia’s youngest child.
    After Soloheadbeg left the McDonnell children orphaned, the family split up, to be taken care of by various family members across Ireland.
    Eventually Michael McDonnell emigrated to the United States, and the rest for me is history!
    While Soloheadbeg is a historic event for Ireland, the McDonnell’s cannot overlook, first and foremost, how our family was deeply affected, and shaped our future.
    I thoroughly enjoy viewing pictures of our great granddad, and would appreciate seeing any more that you may have.
    My husband and I had the great privilege of visiting James Alec’s grave in Tipperary in October 2012.
    Thanks, Cathy McDonnell McQueen, U.S.A.

  • Michael Ryan

    Please contact me re the above.

    I live in Tipperary and part of a committee which wishes to remember the lives of all who participated in the Soloheadbeg ambush.

    Ml Ryan

  • Martin Graham McDonnell Palmer

    I am also the great grandson of of James McDonnell being the grandson of his son James.
    James served in the Royal Airforce in south Africa and on Malta. His children are Barbara, Eileen, Patrick, Jim and Moira (Latter my mother)
    He later settled down in Newport Essex where he ran a very popular Pub called the “Railway Inn”
    Of his other daughters sadly Eileen (Highland) and Barbra (Zink) are no longer with us.
    Barbra moved over to the USA with her husband and had 3 boys, my cousins who we regularly keep in touch with.
    There are two stories I would love to know if are true about James :- it was said that he would often visit pubs and challenge those there to a pint of beer by asking them to spell Chrysanthemum!
    The other story I would like to know more about is at the inquest of his murder one of his sons stood up and shouted “he was never given a chance!” Later in his book Dan Breen suggested that they only fired on the constables in self defense.
    As great grandchildren of this man we have all taken up his surname within our own to honor him.

  • Jim Zink

    James McDonnell was my Great Grand father. I Grand father Joseph McDonnell and my mother Barbara McDonnell. I live in the States. It would be nice to have a reunion states bound- so much I would like to know. My mother passed in 1984. My sons middle name is Donnell in memory.

    Jim Zink

  • Margaret McGrath

    Christopher McDonnell’s wife Bridget McGrath, would anyone know who her parents were????

  • Therese Ryan

    Hi Michael

    Could you contact me if you’re having any form of memorial next year. I’d like to be there.

  • Ronan McGreevy

    My name is Ronan McGreevy from The Irish Times. I would like to use that photograph of James McConnell for a supplement we are doing on 1919.
    Is that OK?


  • Ann Irwin

    Bridget McGrath was the daughter of John McGrath of Glengad. My great grandfather George Irwin, from Lenerevagh, married Mary McGrath from Rossport and an Ellen Irwin who I believe to be his sister married Alec McDonnell. Trying to work out the relationships! Just wondering where exactly Constable James McDonnell was born? I know it’s Belmullet. Where did Christopher go to when his father died?
    Kind regards,
    Ann Irwin

  • Con O'Laoghaire

    Hi, My name is Con O’Laoghaire. My Grandmother was a daughter of James McDonnell. She went into service in various houses after his death before marrying my Grandfather and settling in Harty Place, Dublin. She had three children Imelda, Shea and my father Con.

  • Kevin McDonnell

    Just a hello to all the McDonnell’s and descendent lines, I have been trying to collate a history of anything stemming from James Alec McDonnell (RIC) whose life was cruelly taken a few weeks before he was due to retire back in January 2019. I am very happy to share the work which has benefitted from a number of relatives Paddy, Aileen, Daithi. There are big gaps that I am trying to fill before the stories and details get lost to time.
    Ironically, I am in Australia but would be happy to share or receive any information about the clan. Please email me facts like your mother, father, wife, husband, sons and daughters and grandchildren – date of birth, marriage, death, short paragraph and any relationships.
    Also after I share, please let me have feedback because I may have some things incorrect.

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>




one + 12 =

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

slot gacorslot gacorMurah4dtotoHoras88omo777suara805bandar togelSlot PulsaSlot Danasbobet88livescore bolapay4dslot gacorslotbonus slot BonusSlot88SlotSlot ThailandSlot ThailandSlot 10kSlot DanaRtp SlotSlot OnlineSlot DemoSlot PulsaSlot MaxwinSlot GacorSlot GacorJudi BolaDemo SlotDemo SlotSlot GacorSlot GacorJudi BolaUnogoalSPBOSlot Gacor
slot gacorslot gacorslot777 resmiraja4d resmidewahoki resmidewatoto resmibri4d resmigoaloo resmidewa138 resmiada777 resmispaceman resmi1xbet resmidewa4d resmibigbos4d resmiraja88 resmiakun vip resmiraja303 resmimpo99 resmibet188 resmigacor303 resmislot77 resmiaha4d resmidewaslot88 resmiasiabet88 resmiladangtoto resmisv388 resmimpo4d resmianti rungkad resmiidn slot resmiinfini88 resminexus slot resmiboss88 resmijp88 resmimpo slot resminowgoal resmiunogoal resmipay4d resmi=agen88 resmispbo resmi
raja88 aslidewa4d asliraja303 aslidewa138 aslidewahoki asliraja4d asliindoasli aslidewatoto asli
slot depo pulsaslot depo danartp liveladangtoto 2slot pay4dslot idndewatoto resmiraja4d resmiwbet resmidewa138 resmibigbos4d resmiasia4d resmimpo4d resmimpo99 resmislot303 resmiolo4d resmidewahoki resmislot77 resmibet88 resmicuanwin resmiaha4d resmiasia88 resmi
demo slot pg softjudi sabung ayamslot asia88judi sabung ayamjudi sabung ayamslot aha4d
daftar asia4ddaftar bigbos4ddaftar boss88daftar olo4d
suara805omo777slot dana gacorslot pulsa gacorslot demo gacorslot asia gacormix parlay gacorslot zeus gacorslot koi gate gacorslot mahjong gacorslot sweet bonanza gacorslot pragmatic gacorslot habanero gacorslot toto gacordewa99 gacorbet88 gacorstar777 gacordewagacor gacormawar4d gacorwbet gacorbca4d gacorhoki303 gacordewa138 gacorgacor303 gacor
slot deposit pulsaslot deposit danaslot pay4dslot nexusslot mposlot cuanwinladangtoto2sabung ayam onlineslot infini88
flashscore gacorbola009 gacorbolasiar gacornowgoal gacorfun88 gacorspbo gacorbgibola gacoraiscore gacordragon77 gacorbwin gacorskybet gacordafabet gacortambang88 gacorunogoal gacorgoaloo gacorsky777 gacor90bola gacorgacor4d gacorhasilskor gacormpo4d gacormpo99 gacor
depo xldepo telkomseldepo 100kdepo 50kdepo 10kdepo 25kdepo recehdepo indosatstar7771xbetdewa138dewahokidewa4draja4dasia88asia4dsky777cuanwinslot111olo4dmpo99live22mpo4dmegawinserver mpojp88hoki303gacor303nex4dbet188pragmatic virtualsbobet virtualdigmaancmd368raja303wbetagen88dewaslot88dewatotoserver idnindoslotslot303indowinsv388akun wsoaha4dasia999asia777asiabet88bet77bet365bigbos4dbp77bri4dakun zeusraja88slot777ws168gacor4dakun totopay4dserver nexus
slot kamboja onlineslot taiwan onlineslot singapore onlineslot myanmar onlineslot vietnam onlineslot malaysia onlineslot hongkong onlineslot rusia online
judi slot thailandladangtotojudi bet88judi gacor4djudi sv388judi slot bonusjudi slot303judi bet88judi slot777judi infini88judi gacor4djudi infini88asia88toto togelslot gacorgacor4dslot asia 4dlivescore bolaslot spacemanslot gacor 77livescore bolalivescore bola bet88judi slot77judi slot77judi slot303judi asia4djudi judi88judi cuanwinjudi asia88judi idn slotjudi scatter emasjudi scatter hitamjudi scatter emasjudi cmd368judi nex4djudi slot77judi slot303judi scatter hitamjudi spacemanjudi bolaslot onlineslot gacorakun pro asia
slot gacor gampang menangslot depo via pulsadaftar bet88daftar ladangtotologin slot luar negeridaftar slot jpdaftar infini88daftar slot303daftar idn slotdaftar gacor4ddaftar slot303daftar slot recehdaftar mpo slotdaftar akun pro rusiadaftar pay4ddaftar akun pro hongkongdaftar akun pro hongkongdaftar akun pro kambojadaftar akun pro malaysiadaftar akun pro myanmardaftar akun pro singaporedaftar akun pro thailanddaftar akun pro vietnamdaftar idn slotlogin akun gacorlogin akun vipdaftar slot777slot receh gacorslot303 gacorslot777 gacor
situs slot agen88 pasti maxwinsitus atlasbet88situs cuanwin138situs macanasia88situs slot jp maxwinsitus depo 25 bonus 25situs slot depo 10ksitus slot freebetsitus slot macanasia88
link aiscorelink bgibolalink bolasiarlink nobar bolalink hasilskorlink nobartvlink flashscorelink 90bolalink bola009link live bola malam inilink bola010
BO bandar toto togelsitus slot qrissitus slot bcasitus slot brisitus slot gopaysitus slot ovositus slot bnisitus slot permatasitus slot mandirisitus slot danamonsitus slot linkajapasang parlay cmd368pasang parlay bola011nex4d togel onlinepasang parlay wbetslot pasti gratis saldopasang parlay sbobet virtualdemo slot pragmatic virtualpasang parlay saba bolaslot gacor spacemanslot bonus scatter hitamjudi casino baccarat online
situs slot 25ksitus slot 10ksitus parlay bolasitus 188betsitus bet188situs dragon77situs fun88situs olo4dsitus situs4dsitus sky777situs star777situs tambang88situs we88
slot depo 10k tanpa potongansbobet88 judi sportbookslot server thailand terbaikslot server kamboja terbaikslot bonus new member 100 di awalslot anti rungkad 100slot server asiaslot mpo engineslot nexus engineslot pay4d engineslot akun vipslot akun gacorslot idn engineslot ladangtoto2
situs slot303situs mahjong wayssitus hoki303situs bet77situs bp77situs asia88situs slot garansi kekalahansitus mpo4dsitus wsositus judi bolasitus totositus slot gampang menangsitus cuanwin138situs bigbos4dsitus slot danasitus bocoran adminsitus asia777situs 1xbetsitus macanasia88situs atlasbet88situs rtp gacorsitus bri4dsitus asia999situs pastijpsitus asiabet88situs bet365
situs slot thailandslot777 gacorsitus akun gacorsitus akun vipsitus nowgoalsitus spbositus unogoallive draw taiwanlive draw cambodialive draw chinascatter biru diamond freespin 45xscatter hitam emas freespin 45xscatter hijau emas freespin 45xscatter hitam hijau freespin 45xscatter hitam pink freespin 45xscatter pink hitam freespin 45xscatter hitam kuning freespin 45xscatter ungu putih freespin 45xdepo 100k bonus 100kslot freebet 100 ribulive draw jakartalive draw korealive draw macaulive draw sdylive draw sgplive draw japandemo slot reel kingdomslot gacor mahjong ways 2demo slot microgamingdemo slot cq9demo slot live22bet88 judi bolademo slot jokerdemo slot advantplayraja slot anti rungkaddemo slot nolimit citydemo slot spadegamingslot atlasbet88cheat slot gacorlive draw hkslot atlasbet88slot atlasbet88slot maxwin hari inislot gacor slot777
situs server luar negerisitus slot anti rungkadsitus slot demositus atlasbet88situs slot asiasitus slot pragmaticsitus bet88situs atlasbet88situs slot recehsitus slot hokisitus sv388situs asia4dsitus slot pg softsitus macanasia88situs akun pro jepangsitus atlasbet88situs akun pro taiwansitus akun pro myanmarsitus akun pro vietnamsitus akun pro hongkongsitus slot danasitus cuanwin138situs akun pro thailandsitus akun pro kambojasitus akun pro rusiasitus akun pro malaysiasitus akun pro singaporesitus cuanwin138situs akun pro thailandsitus cuanwin138situs macanasia88situs atlasbet88situs akun gacorsitus macanasia88situs spbositus judi bolasitus sbobet88situs bonus new membersitus parlay bolasitus akun vipsitus unogoalsitus slot depo 25ksitus slot depo 10ksitus macanasia88situs cuanwin138situs slot777situs ladangtoto
omo77situs slot deposit bonus 100+100situs slot deposit bonus 100+50situs slot777situs slot 5 lionssitus mpo slotsitus atlasbet88situs slot bonanza goldsitus slot big basssitus nexus slotsitus idn slotsitus pay4dsitus slot esportsitus slot aztec gemssitus macanasia88situs slot digmaansitus asia4dsitus cuanwin138situs slot fa caisitus slot koi gatesitus cuanwin138situs slot spacemansitus slot sugar rushsitus slot twilight princesssitus atlasbet88situs atlasbet88situs macanasia88situs bet88login 90bolalogin bgibolalogin bola009login nobartvlogin aiscorelogin bolasiarlogin live bola malam inilogin streaming bolalogin flashscorelogin hasilskorlogin slot server kuala lumpurlogin slot server arab saudilogin slot server phnom penhlogin slot server timor timurlogin slot server macaulogin slot server sydneylogin slot server korealogin slot habanerologin slot server ghanalogin slot server mexicologin slot server argentinalogin slot server mesirlogin slot server palestinalogin slot server jordanlogin slot server yordanialogin slot server iranlogin slot server iraklogin slot server brazillogin slot server lebanonlogin slot server uruguay
situs mix parlaysitus sbobetsitus bet88situs cmd368situs saba bolasitus taruhan bola jalansitus 90minsitus wbetsitus sbobet88situs goaloo
idn slot resmimpo slot resmislot77 resmiasia777 resmiada777 resmiasia999 resmibni4d resmibigbos4d resmibet188 resmisitus4d resmibri4d resmibet88 resmi
gacor4d resmislot77 resmiinfini88 resmiasia4d resmiasia88 resmislot303 resmislot gacor resmisitus slot maxwinsitus qq onlinesitus shio togelsitus adu sakongsitus cheat slotsitus agen88situs asia88situs sv388situs slot303situs slot777
bet 88gacor 4didn slotinfini 88mpo slotnexus slotpay4d slotsbobet resmislot 77sabung ayam onlineakun slot gacorakun slot vipslot anti rungkadasia 4djudi bola onlineladang toto 2livescore nowgoallivescore spbolivescore unogoalviral 4dakun slot hongkongakun slot jepangakun slot kambojaakun slot malaysiaakun slot myanmarakun slot rusiaakun slot singaporeakun slot taiwanakun slot thailandakun slot vietnam
slot bonus new member 100% slot deposit dana 10k demo slot gratis tanpa daftar slot deposit 10k slot deposit 25k slot gacor hari ini slot deposit pulsa 10k slot server kamboja slot server thailand slot 88 slot asia slot habanero slot pasti hoki slot jp slot mania slot jamin maxwin slot pg soft slot pragmatic play slot receh slot rtp live
wbet onlinepay4d onlineasia4d onlinedewa4d onlineasia88 onlineada777 onlineasia777 onlineaha4d onlineslot77 onlinebet88 onlinepay4d onlineboss88 onlineslot thailand onlineslot thailand onlineslot nexus online
anti rungkad asliakun vip asliakun gacor aslimahjong ways aslispaceman aslislot88 aslislot777 aslisbobet88 aslireceh slot aslimpo slot aslimania slot aslinexus slot asliasia slot asliwso slot asli188bet aslidewa4d aslicmd368 asliasia999 asliasiabet88 asliasia777 aslibri4d aslibet77 asliinfini4d aslibp77 aslihoki303 asliboss88 aslibet365 aslibet188 aslijp88 aslimegawin aslislot111 aslidragon77 aslidafabet aslisky777 aslistar777 asligacor303 asliskybet asliada777 aslibetway asli1win aslibwin asliwe88 aslitambang88 asli90bola aslibgibola aslibola009 aslispbo aslinobartv asliunogoal aslinowgoal asli
sbobet88 gacorladangtoto gacorasia999 gacorasiabet88 gacorolo4d gacorada777 gacorbp77 gacorbet88 gacorslot77 gacorbet188 gacorgacor303 gacorbigbos4d gacoraha4d gacorbri4d gacormpo4d gacor
situs bet188situs infini4dsitus sv388situs ada777situs bri4dsitus asia777situs situs4dsitus wbetsitus slot77situs bet88situs aha4dsitus olo4d
idn slot onlinepay4d slot onlinempo slot onlinenexus slot onlineladangtoto onlineslot maxwin onlinebp77 onlinedewa138 onlinegacor4d onlineslot77 onlinegacor303 onlineasia4d onlinebigbos4d onlinecuanwin onlinebet188 onlineasia999 onlineada777 onlineasia88 onlinebca4d onlineasia777 onlinebet88 onlinebri4d onlineolo4d onlineslot303 onlineinfini4d onlinemuara77 onlinesitus4d onlineaha4d onlinebni4d online188bet online