Archives

Ireland’s Proposed €100 Culture Voucher – Good Investment Or A Budget Sweetener?

A Possible Budget Leak – With Questions Still Unanswered.

Reports ahead of Ireland’s Budget 2027 suggest that all 16-year-olds could receive a €100 voucher for arts and cultural activities, with a possible extension to 17-year-olds in Budget 2028. The estimated first-year cost is €7.5 million. This remains a reported proposal, rather than a confirmed entitlement.
Whether the announcement has emerged through a deliberate leak has not been established.

Helping young people experience culture most certainly is a worthwhile ambition. But taxpayers are entitled to ask what this particular measure would achieve, and whether another approach would achieve much more.

Cultural Spending on those aged 16 year does not automatically mean education
A play, concert or creative workshop can spark an interest that can last a lifetime. Enjoyment and shared experiences have value also. However, redeeming a voucher does not prove that someone has learned something new or discovered an activity they would otherwise have missed.

France’s experience offers a warning.
Its national auditors found that the ‘Culture Pass’ mainly reinforced established cultural habits, while its ability to broaden participation remained limited.
Ireland should learn from that experience, before assuming a voucher will overcome barriers to culture.
The test is whether the Government sets clear objectives, publishes the costs and commissions an independent evaluation. Success should mean reaching young people who currently miss out, not simply announcing how many vouchers were spent.

Could It Free Money For Alcohol or Drug Abuse?
If a teenager already planned to buy a concert ticket, a voucher could leave their own money available for something else.
But it would be unfair to assume that the money would go towards alcohol or drugs. It might pay for transport, food or savings. There is no evidence presented here establishing that this proposal would increase substance use.
Will Ticket Prices Rise And Who Gets the Money?
Extra purchasing power could put upward pressure on prices where popular events already sell out. At venues with empty seats, it could instead increase attendance without raising prices. Most popular bands on Tour entering Ireland already cost well over €100
Some spending could benefit wealthy performers, major promoters and ticketing platforms. Other spending could support local theatres, musicians and cultural organisations which command much less cost.
The Government should monitor prices and publish where the money goes. Public subsidy deserves scrutiny even when the product being sold is culture.

Could €7.5 Million Expected Spend Achieve More Elsewhere?
A comparison might be sustained music tuition, youth clubs, instrument lending, school cultural visits and transport for disadvantaged or rural teenagers.
A voucher cannot solve the problem of having no accessible venue or no way to get there. Supporting participation may require people, facilities and transport as well as purchasing power.
Poorer children deserve cultural opportunities too. The question is which approach gives them the most meaningful access.

“For Ye Have the Poor Always With You”
The moral question remains relevant for Christians; does this prospective spending meaningfully help those excluded, or mainly subsidise those already well able to participate?
Matthew 26:11 should be read in context; Jesus defends a woman’s anointing of him, with expensive perfumed oil, which he connects with his burial. We should not interpret it as permission to neglect poverty.
Deuteronomy 15:11 (Second Law) acknowledges that poverty persists while calling for generosity towards those in need.

My Own Personal View: Let’s Test this Before Expanding It.
I would support a limited, independently evaluated pilot, with extra support for disadvantaged teenagers and opportunities to take part in local creative activities.
France’s experience shows why this matters. Its national auditors found weaker participation among young people from less advantaged backgrounds and questioned how far a primarily financial scheme could overcome existing inequalities.

Create Opportunities to Make and Perform
To my mind the pilot should offer opportunities to learn an instrument, join a drama group, make a short film, try photography or attend a series of creative workshops.
Taking part in an activity over several weeks offers a much better chance to develop skills, friendships and confidence. The pilot should test both approaches, while preserving young people’s choice.
Here in Thurles Co. Tipperary, as in many other Irish communities, we already have organisations that could greatly inform this work.
Music Generation, for example, supports local access to vocal and instrumental tuition for children and young people. Partnership opportunities should be explored, with funding for any additional places and teaching required.

Measure What Changes Because of the Support. The independent evaluation should ask:

  • Did teenagers start activities they would otherwise have missed?
  • Did the scheme reach those with the greatest barriers?
  • Did participation continue six or twelve months later?
  • What did participants learn, enjoy or find difficult?
  • What was the full cost, including administration, transport and additional support?
  • Did spending support local provision, and were there changes in prices or fees?

Researchers should record participation before any pilot and use a fair comparison, such as a phased rollout, to help distinguish the scheme’s effects from changes that would have happened anyway. They should also speak to teenagers who never used the offer or stopped attending.
If the results are strong, expansion would have a credible foundation. If benefits mainly go to teenagers already participating, the scheme should be redesigned.
Support would rest on a clear purpose; giving young people a fair chance to discover, enjoy and develop their creativity and showing that public money greatly helped make that possible.

Before expansion, the Government should demonstrate new participation, fair access and reasonable value for money.

Autumn In Thurles, Co. Tipperary – Surprising Story Of Conkers, Soap And First World War.

Autumn in Thurles Co. Tipperary brings golden leaves, cooler mornings and shiny brown conkers found beneath horse-chestnut trees.

For many, they recall the childhood game; a conker threaded onto a string, swung against an opponent’s until one cracked. These familiar seeds also have an unexpected connection to the First World War, a story linking plant starch, bacteria and soap-making to the production of ammunition.

The story begins with starch. Conkers store starch to support a developing seedling. During WWI, that starch attracted interest as a possible raw material for producing acetone, a solvent needed in British cordite manufacture.

Chemist Dr Chaim Weizmann♦ (Wife Dr Vera Khatzmann MD), developed a process that used bacteria to turn starchy materials into useful industrial solvents. In broad terms, bacterial enzymes broke down starch into smaller sugars, which the bacteria then metabolised. The resulting fermentation produced acetone alongside alcohols, particularly butanol. Latter butanol is a permitted artificial flavour used in butter, cream, fruit, rum, whiskey, ice ices, candy, baked goods and cordials. Distillation separated the useful liquids from the fermented mixture by exploiting differences in their volatility. Dr Weizmann’s patent describes this combination of fermentation and separation HERE.

As wartime shortages put pressure on maize supplies, Britain looked for other sources of starch to produce acetone. In autumn 1917, schoolchildren, Scouts and other volunteers collected conkers in the hope that horse chestnuts could replace some of the grain being used in the process. Despite enthusiastic collecting, transport and processing difficulties hampering the scheme, many such conkers went unused.

♦ Same Dr Chaim Weizmann was an Israeli statesman, biochemist, and Zionist leader who served as the first president of Israel.
His elder son, Mr Benjamin (Benjie) Weizmann (1907–1980), with wife Minnie “Madeline” (Mady) Pomerantz, would later settled here in Ireland, following his service in the British Royal Artillery during World War II, settling just across the west Tipperary border in ‘Doonass House’, Clonlara, Co. Clare, just 62km
(38.5 miles) from Thurles; becoming a dairy farmer, before selling out and moving to retire in Jersey in the Channel Islands.

Doonass House, Clonlara, Clare, which today is a burnt out ruin.

Where did cordite come in?
Cordite was a smokeless propellant; its burning generated gases that drove a bullet or shell along a gun barrel. Its principal energetic ingredients included nitrocellulose, also called guncotton, and nitroglycerine.
For cordite formulations using acetone, the solvent helped turn the ingredients into a workable material that could be shaped into cords. It was subsequently removed during drying, with factories recovering solvent for reuse. Acetone’s role was therefore in processing the propellant.

Soap-making supplied another part of the story. In traditional soap manufacture, fats or oils react with an alkali in a process called saponification. This produces soap and glycerine, also known as glycerol.
Manufacturers could recover that glycerine and supply it to the munitions industry, where it became a raw material for nitroglycerine.

Conkers have a further washing connection of their own. They contain saponin, naturally occurring compounds with detergent-like properties. These molecules have both water-attracting and water-repelling parts, helping explain their ability to foam and assist cleaning. This is a different chemical story from either starch fermentation or conventional soap manufacture.

A conker beneath a Tipperary tree can prompt questions reaching far beyond childhood games, into plant biology, industrial fermentation and the demands that war places on everyday materials.

INTO Teachers Announce October Industrial Action Over Pay Deal Delays

Primary school teachers represented by the Irish National Teachers’ Organisation (INTO) are set to begin industrial action on October 5th, amid delays in securing a new public sector pay agreement.

The action will begin with a work-to-rule, with members also due to join other public sector workers in a proposed nationwide strike on Wednesday, October 14th next.

According to the INTO, members in primary and special schools will restrict their work to contracted daily teaching hours. They will withdraw co-operation with additional hours, including those introduced under the Croke Park Agreement, until further notice.

The decision follows a ballot in which 99.5% of participating members supported industrial action. Turnout stood at 57.5%.
INTO General Secretary Mr John Boyle said the result demonstrated a strong mandate from teachers facing financial pressures. He said uncertainty over salaries, alongside the cost-of-living crisis, was fuelling members’ frustration.
The INTO is the latest public sector union to support industrial action, accusing the Government of failing to put forward a meaningful pay offer.

The previous public sector pay agreement expired on June 30th, and formal negotiations on a replacement have yet to begin.
Responding to the announcement, the Department of Public Expenditure expressed disappointment that unions had not taken opportunities to engage in recent weeks.

A spokesperson urged both sides to return to negotiations, saying progress towards a new agreement would require constructive, sustained engagement without preconditions.

Adults And Children’s events Taking Place In Cashel Library Next Week

Below are details of next week’s Adults and Children’s events in Cashel Library.

Ms Maura Barrett, Reports From Cashel Library, Co. Tipperary:

Monday 21st September – at 11:00am – Comhrá sa Leabharlann – Do you want to practice your cúpla focal? Bain triail as do chúpla focal sa leabharlann Chaiseal Mumhan. Tá fáilte roimh gach duine, (Translated – Try out a few words of Irish at the Cashel Library. Everyone is welcome).

Monday 21st September – at 2:0.30pm – Learn English – Free Conversation English Classes.

Tuesday 22nd September – at 1:30pm – Free Lecture – Dr Damian Gleeson on Fr John Joseph Therry founder of Australian Catholicism and his acquired wealth and unethical dealings (New Research).

Wednesday 23rd September – at 10:00am – Cashel Craft Circle Cashel. Bring along your own project to work, share ideas, patterns and enjoy a chat and a cuppa with others. All welcome.

Friday 25th September – at 10:00am – Toddler Story time.

Friday 25th September – at 3.30pm – LEGO Free Play – Strictly ages 7 years plus.

Please Note: Booking is essential to attend at FREE events, so please Tel: 062-63825, to be sure of a seat.

You can locate the Cashel Library building, situated on Friar Street, Lady’s Well, Cashel, Co. Tipperary, HERE. [Eircode E25 K798]

The Tipperary Bogs That Built A Community – Littleton’s Bord na Móna Stories

Local History Group Celebrates Littleton’s Bord na Móna Heritage.

The people, places and memories of Littleton’s peat industry will take centre stage at the book launch of “Bord na Móna: Littleton Story” in the Horse & Jockey Hotel, Thurles, on Friday, 25th September, at 8.00 pm.

Presented by the Moycarkey / Borris Littleton Men’s Shed and Community History Group, this local history publication celebrates the men and women whose working lives helped shape the community, preserving stories of the bogs, the machinery and a legacy that reaches far beyond the workplace. Former employees, their families and everyone with an interest in the area’s heritage are warmly invited to attend.

The Littleton Bog complex is a term used by the Moycarkey / Borris / Littleton Men’s Shed and Community History Group to outline the area of peatlands worked on an industrial scale by Bord na Móna since the company was founded in 1946. With the cessation of works at the the Littleton Briquette Factory and milled peat operations in April 2018, it brought to a close sixty-two years of peat extraction works at this area of peatlands.

This book, while not endeavouring to be an in-depth historical analysis of Bord na Móna operations in the middle of Tipperary; provides a snapshot of its impact on the parish of Moycarkey / Borris / Littleton. Other parishes in the area such as Moyne / Templetuohy; Gortnahoe / Glengoole and Killenaule also had very important roles in the growth and development of the bogs as areas of employment and add greatly to the overall story of the relevance and importance of Bord na Móna to these communities. People from Thurles and other surrounding parishes were also employed on the bog or in the briquette factory. Indeed, it must also be recognised that the site of Littleton Briquette Factory is in the townland of Killeens, which is part of Killenaule parish.

This booklet gives a brief overview of the turf cutting operations at the outset of the development of the bogs, with the main focus being on the offices and yard at Ballybeg. This new industry meant that many men were required to get operations up and running, with the result that several of these came from outside Tipperary, many of whom resided in a billet camp, which was sited across the road from the main office and yard. It is not meant to be an exhaustive account of the work which took place in the Littleton Bog complex or within the area of work associated with the briquette factory. For a comprehensive overview of the history of Bord na Móna readers are encouraged to read Brown Gold: (A History of Bord na Móna and the Irish Peat Industry by Donal Clarke).

The type of work engaged on the bogs is explored, as is a brief exploration of the various machines which were required to work the bogs on such an industrial scale. Coupled with the influx of workers and families was a need for social housing and this is also chronicled with an overview of housing schemes, school development and an associated impact on sporting and social organisations across the parish.

It is also recognised that the peatlands of mid-Tipperary have a rich and vibrant history, which have engaged all peoples across the generations. A sample overview of the flora and fauna of the bogs, its relevance as a carbon sink in the modern era and how the rich tapestry of its past can be used to educate and inform people as the impact of climate change is felt locally and globally.

Many parts of the bog were given local place names, which were readily identifiable to the Bord na Móna workers. Many of these are also recorded so that this local knowledge is not lost and can continue as part of the vibrant folklore associated with a lifetime for many of working on the bogs.

Lastly, an overview of archaeological finds in the bog, both before and during Bord na Móna operations are also recorded. These assist in demonstrating the relevance of the bogs as spiritual, votive, social, energy and recreational areas, which are all intertwined across the generations.

Acknowledgments
The Moycarkey Borris Littleton Men’s Shed and Community History Group are thankful to everyone who assisted with this Bord na Móna story in the parish community.
To those who supplied articles and photographs: Colm Dempsey BnM, Ray Yates, Tommy Maguire, Frank Connolly, Liam Dempsey, Fr. Tomás O’Connell, Christy Bracken, Ann Slattery, Billy Loughnane, Peggy Kirby, Billy Ryan, M. Skehan Ruddy, Tom Kelly, Ed. O’Shea, Sean Ryan, Sadie Dwyer, John O’Loughlin, Martin Cooney and members of the group who also contributed articles.
A special word of thanks to Clare McNamara, Image Library Officer, National Museum of Ireland for her support and for the kind permission of the National Museum to reproduce images of some items discovered in the Littleton Bog Complex.
Thanks to Dr. Charles Mount for his kind permission to reproduce a ‘Togher/Tocher’ (wooden trackway), following excavation at Longfordpass. The MBL Men’s Shed and Community History Group are Michael Dempsey, Jim Flanagan, Seamus Bourke, John Fogarty, Liam O’Donnchú, Mary Ryan, Mary and Frank O’Regan, Billy Purcell, Joe Moran and Pat Bracken. Thanks also to Tommy Britton for his support and a special word of thanks to Bernie Lonergan who co-ordinated the project at the outset.

Dedication
This overview of the impact of the bogs of mid-Tipperary on the community of Moycarkey / Borris / Littleton could not have been possible without telling some of the stories of the life and times of the men and women who worked in the Littleton Bog complex under the employment of Bord na Móna. This booklet is dedicated to all these people, and to the legacy which they have left behind. To those still living, we salute and thank you. To those who have gone to their eternal reward; Ar dheis dé go raibh a n-anamacha. (Irish translation – “May their souls be on the right hand of God”).