Archives

€20m Armoured Vehicle Fleet Raises Serious Questions Over Value For Money

A multimillion-euro purchase of armoured vehicles for Ireland’s Defence Forces has come under renewed scrutiny after the State’s spending watchdog concluded that the fleet delivered substantially less value than had been expected.

The Department of Defence purchased 27 RG-32M Light Tactical Armoured Vehicles from BAE Systems in South Africa in 2008, at a total cost of approximately €19.6 million. The vehicles were intended to bridge the operational gap between ordinary “soft-skinned” military vehicles and heavier armoured personnel carriers, giving Defence Forces personnel greater protection and mobility in potentially dangerous environments.

However, the Comptroller and Auditor General has found that the Defence Forces did not receive the level of service anticipated from the fleet. Although the vehicles were expected to remain operational for around 20 years, they were withdrawn from active service in December 2023, roughly six years earlier than originally planned.

RG-32M Light Tactical Armoured Vehicles.

Usage of some vehicles was remarkably low. The watchdog found that average annual mileage across the fleet was below 1,500 kilometres per vehicle, while individual vehicles recorded even lower levels of activity. Questions were also raised about the reliability of mileage records, with gaps and problems involving odometers leading the auditor to identify what it described as a serious fleet-management control failure.

Mechanical and logistical difficulties further reduced the usefulness of the fleet. Technical problems included drivetrain issues, while obtaining replacement parts was frequently difficult and resulted in delays to repairs and reduced vehicle availability.

Despite the fleet’s relatively limited use, the vehicles were deployed on overseas missions, including operations in Lebanon and Syria, as well as being used for training in Ireland.

The Department of Defence recorded an impairment, or write-down, of €2.77 million on the fleet. The Comptroller and Auditor General concluded, however, that the overall loss of value to the State was significantly greater because the vehicles were withdrawn early and had apparently seen relatively light use during their service lives.

The retired vehicles were subsequently offered to Ukraine, but the Ukrainian Armed Forces declined them after determining that they were unsuitable for their requirements. No final decision had been made on their disposal when the auditor reported.

The episode provides an important case study in the long-term costs associated with major defence procurement. Buying specialised military equipment involves much more than the initial purchase price: reliability, spare-parts availability, maintenance arrangements, accurate fleet records and the expected operational lifespan all play a major role in determining whether taxpayers ultimately receive value for money.

The Department of Defence has said lessons have been learned from the procurement and that purchasing procedures have changed significantly since 2008, with greater emphasis now being placed on the full life-cycle costs and sustainability of expensive military equipment.

With Ireland planning substantial further investment in Defence Forces equipment in the years ahead, the findings underline the importance of rigorous procurement, long-term logistical support and effective oversight of major public expenditure.

Ireland Should Move Forward On Plug-In Solar

We recently looked into why small plug-in solar systems, sometimes called balcony solar, are widely available in countries such as Germany but are still difficult to use in Ireland.

Irish households are paying some of the highest electricity prices in Europe. Eurostat reported that Ireland had the highest household electricity price in the EU in the second half of 2025, at €40.42 per 100 kWh compared with an EU average of €28.96. At prices like these, people should have access to every safe and affordable way of reducing the amount of electricity they have to buy from the grid.

Balcony Solar

Small plug-in solar systems will not solve Ireland’s energy-cost problem, but they could give households a simple and relatively low-cost way to generate some of their own electricity. If certified 800-watt systems can be used safely elsewhere in Europe, Ireland should move quickly to establish clear standards, simple registration and approved products so Irish consumers can benefit too.

The answer is surprisingly simple. The solar panels themselves are not the problem. The main issue is how our electrical and grid rules currently treat them.
In Germany, households can buy small solar kits, often around 800 watts, connect an approved micro-inverter and register the system through a simplified process.
Some of these complete systems are sold by retailers such as Lidl for only a few hundred euro.

In Ireland, however, a small plug-in system is currently treated much more like a conventional solar installation. Grid-connected solar generally has to comply with ESB Networks requirements, Irish electrical standards and microgeneration connection rules.
That makes a €300–€500 DIY solar kit far less practical here.

The good news is that Ireland is now actively examining the issue. The Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment has been considering plug-in mini-solar, together with ESB Networks and other relevant bodies. Safety issues, including how electricity flows back through household circuits are part of that work.
Nobody is suggesting that electrical safety should be ignored. But other European countries have shown that small solar systems can operate within clear limits, using approved equipment and appropriate registration.

For Ireland, the important questions are now straightforward:

  • What maximum output should be allowed?
  • What safety standards should the inverter meet?
  • What electrical protections are required?
  • Can consumers register an approved system through a simple online process?

Once those questions are settled, Ireland can publish clear rules so consumers and retailers know exactly where they stand.
Small plug-in solar will not replace rooftop solar farms or large home PV systems. But it could give people living in apartments, rented homes or houses, where a full solar installation isn’t practical, another way to generate some of their own electricity.
It could also lower the entry cost of solar from several thousand euro to a few hundred euro.

Ireland has already spent considerable time examining this technology. The next useful step is for the Government, ESB Networks, CRU, NSAI and Safe Electric to complete that work and publish a clear, safe framework.

If an approved 800-watt solar kit can be safely used by households elsewhere in Europe, Ireland deserves a clear answer on how, and under what conditions, the same technology can be used here.

Let’s get the rules settled and give Irish consumers clarity.

Tipperary’s River Suir And Ireland’s Wild Atlantic Salmon – A Serious Decline

Ireland’s wild Atlantic salmon are in serious decline.

Scientific estimates indicate that well over one million salmon returned to Irish rivers annually during much of the 1970s; in recent years that figure has fallen below 200,000. Inland Fisheries Ireland’s Technical Expert Group says the decline reflects pressures both at sea and in freshwater.

Atlantic Salmon.

For Tipperary and the River Suir, this is not an abstract national problem. The Suir is one of Ireland’s great salmon rivers and Atlantic salmon is a protected qualifying species within the Lower River Suir Special Area of Conservation, which extends through Tipperary, and Waterford.

The latest scientific assessment for the 2026 season groups the Suir, with the river Clodiagh near Holycross, and river Lingaun latter part of the border between Kilkenny and Tipperary, and Waterford Blackwater. At the standard 75% probability of achieving its conservation limit, the stock was recommended for catch-and-release fishing only, rather than having a harvestable surplus. Under more precautionary probability thresholds, the advice is now to close it.

Domestic effluent allowed to flow into the River Suir for past 10 years unabated.

What is happening to our salmon?
There is no single cause. Poor survival at sea certainly is a major part of the national decline, with changing ocean temperatures, food availability and wider changes in the North Atlantic affecting salmon after they leave Irish rivers.
But what happens inside rivers such as the Suir also matters enormously. Salmon need clean, cool, well-oxygenated flowing water and clean gravel beds in which to spawn. The female buries her eggs among the stones. Water must circulate freely through that gravel to supply oxygen.
When fine soil, silt and other sediment fill the spaces between the stones, the gravel can become clogged. Water circulation falls and the supply of oxygen to salmon eggs can be reduced. In badly affected spawning beds, eggs and newly hatched fish can die even though the surface of the river may look relatively normal.

Pollution and excessive nutrients are therefore important concerns. The EPA says agriculture and wastewater remain the greatest challenges to Irish water quality, with nitrogen and phosphorus still too high in many waters. In 2026 the EPA also reported that nitrogen remains particularly high across much of the south and southeast, with agriculture the main national source of nitrogen entering rivers. Environmental Protection Agency Tipperary has had direct examples of pollution affecting the Suir. In 2025 Inland Fisheries Ireland secured a conviction following a September 2024 incident at Holycross, where harmful matter entered the River Suir and approximately 400 metres of river bed was reported as having a yellowish-cream deposit. IFI warned that aluminium sulphate entering a river poses a major threat to aquatic ecosystems. Inland Fisheries Ireland

That incident should not be taken as the explanation for the long-term decline of the Suir salmon stock, but it demonstrates how vulnerable the river remains to individual pollution events on top of longer-term pressures.

Rubbish blocking the river while an over abundance of reeds steal the oxygen.

Barriers are another major issue on the Suir Weirs, dams, culverts and other structures can prevent or delay salmon reaching spawning grounds. They can also change river flows and alter the natural movement of gravel and sediment.
A very relevant Tipperary example is Bakery Weir in Cahir. IFI assessed the structure in 2018 and found it to be a significant barrier to migrating salmonids, as well as lamprey and coarse fish. Eight years later, a project is now being progressed to partially remove the weir and improve the natural river channel and fish passage.
IFI explains more generally that barriers can stop fish reaching breeding habitat, increase the energy salmon need to expend during migration and interfere with the movement of the gravels and sediment needed to create healthy spawning beds.

So is pollution, lack of oxygen and clogged gravel responsible?
They are certainly a large part of the problem and they are factors we can actually do something about locally.
But the scientific evidence points to several pressures acting together:

  • poor survival of salmon at sea;
  • agricultural and wastewater pollution;
  • excess nutrients;
  • fine sediment clogging spawning gravel;
  • loss and alteration of river habitat;
  • barriers such as weirs and culverts;
  • warmer water, drought and extreme floods associated with climate change;
  • and other pressures including disease, predation and aquaculture.

The worrying point for Co. Tipperary is that we cannot control what happens to salmon throughout the North Atlantic, but we can improve the River Suir and its tributaries.
That means protecting spawning gravel from excessive silt, reducing nutrient and pollution losses, improving sewage and wastewater treatment, restoring damaged river habitat, protecting river banks and riparian vegetation, and removing or modifying unnecessary barriers so that salmon can once again reach as much good spawning habitat as is possible. If young salmon leave the Suir in greater numbers and in better condition, they have a better chance of surviving the increasingly difficult journey at sea.
The River Suir has supported wild Atlantic salmon for thousands of years. Their decline should be treated as a warning about the health of the entire river system, not simply as an angling issue.
Protecting the salmon means protecting the River Suir, its tributaries, its spawning gravels and its water quality throughout County Tipperary and beyond.

Thurles Planning Alert From Tipperary County Council

Application Ref: 26104
Applicant: Jean and Gina Engela
Development Address: 16 Hazelwood Grove, Thurles, Co. Tipperary, (Eircode E41 R2R8).
Development Description: As constructed home gym/hobby room to rear of dwelling with all associated site work and ancillary works
Status: Conditional.
Application Received: 04/08/2026.
Decision Date: 25/09/2026.
Further Details: http://www.eplanning.ie/TipperaryCC/AppFileRefDetails/26104/0

Tipperary Must Be Part Of Any Conversation On Consent And Victim-Blaming

Consent, Responsibility and the Conversation Tipperary Needs to Have.

New research from the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre should prompt a serious conversation about attitudes to rape, consent and responsibility in Ireland.
According to its latest national survey, 15% of adults believe that someone raped, while under the influence of alcohol or drugs, is at least partly responsible for what happened to them.
Among men under 25 years, that figure rises sharply to 37%. Among women under 25 years, it is 25%.

The wider findings are equally concerning. Almost half of men under 25 years surveyed believe there are “a lot” of false rape allegations, while roughly one in three say a rape should not be believed without either a criminal conviction or a report to Gardaí.
These attitudes matter because sexual violence does not always result in an immediate report, prosecution or conviction. The same research found that among people who had experienced rape, only 17% reported it to Gardaí, while 19% told nobody at all.

Alcohol or drug use does not transfer responsibility for rape from the perpetrator to the victim. Consent must still be freely given, and a person’s vulnerability is never permission for another person to violate them.
But simply condemning young people who hold these views will not solve the problem either.
We need to understand where these beliefs are coming from; what young people are learning about sex and consent, what they are seeing online, how pornography, peer culture and social media may shape expectations, and whether our education system is giving young people the tools to recognise healthy sexual relationships and boundaries.

The encouraging finding is that 88% of adults agree that a perpetrator who is intoxicated should remain just as responsible for their actions.
That principle should be equally clear on the other side of the equation; being intoxicated does not make a victim responsible for somebody else’s decision to commit sexual violence.
Education about consent cannot be a one-off classroom lesson. It needs to involve families, schools, universities, sporting organisations, online platforms and, importantly, men speaking with other men.

Changing attitudes is part of preventing harm and the starting point should be simple; responsibility for rape lies with the person who commits it, not with the person who experiences it.