ESB Networks Under Pressure to Explain Smart Meter Failure and Full Extent of Data Error.
ESB Networks is facing mounting pressure to provide a full and transparent account of how an internal software failure was allowed to generate grossly inaccurate smart meter readings for customers across Ireland, triggering alarm, confusion and serious questions about oversight, safeguards and accountability. The company has confirmed that a planned software upgrade carried out last Friday led to some electricity usage data being processed incorrectly, resulting in highly inflated figures appearing on customer accounts and supplier platforms.
You may check your ‘not so smart’ reading HERE, if you can trust the system.
Emotionally overwhelmed eletric wiring on display located at Ikerrin Road Thurles, Co. Tipperary. “Behold sky spaghetti”. Somewhere inside that knot is one cable doing all the work. Pic: G.Willoughby.
While ESB Networks has apologised for the “confusion and concern” caused, the seriousness of the incident goes far beyond inconvenience. Customers reported seeing apparent one-day electricity costs rise to extraordinary levels, in some cases hundreds or even thousands of euro, with usage figures so extreme that they should have been immediately recognised as impossible, by any functioning validation system. Reports included daily costs of €738 and €2,500; figures that have prompted widespread disbelief and anger.
The incident has exposed what appears to be a major failure in internal controls. If abnormal readings of that scale were able to pass through ESB Networks’ systems and appear on customer-facing accounts, it raises unavoidable questions about the adequacy of testing, monitoring and escalation procedures surrounding critical software changes. A planned upgrade to a nationally significant metering system should not have been capable of producing such obviously absurd outcomes without immediate containment. That it did so points to a deeply troubling lapse in operational assurance.
Perhaps most damaging is the lack of clarity over duration. ESB Networks has identified the trigger as last Friday’s software upgrade, but there is still no full public explanation of how long the issue remained live, when it was first detected internally, how many customers were affected, or whether warning signs emerged before the problem became visible to the public. In the absence of that detail, there is every reason for customers to ask whether this issue was caught promptly at all, or whether it only gained urgency once consumers began highlighting impossible charges online.
ESB Networks has insisted that the issue is internal, that smart meters themselves remain reliable, and that affected data will be corrected automatically with no action required from customers. But reassurance alone is unlikely to restore confidence. With smart meters intended to deliver accuracy, transparency and trust, this episode represents a significant reputational failure. ESB Networks must now do more than fix the numbers; it must explain, in full, how this happened, how long it persisted, and why customers were left to discover the problem before the system did.
A series of events will take place in Waterford city this weekend to commemorate the life and legacy of Thomas Francis Meagher, with particular reflection on his role in the Young Ireland rebellion, the rising at Ballingarry in South Tipperary, and the dramatic events that led to his arrest and transportation to Van Diemen’s Land.
Signatures of Thomas Francis Meagher and Patrick O’Donoghue, both arrested at Rathcannon, Holycross, Thurles, Co. Tipperary, following the 1848 Ballingarry (SR) rebellion. Both signatures are written on the back of a prison library book called “Wreath of Friendship”. Picture: G. Willoughby.
Although Meagher is forever associated with raising the tricolour at the Wolfe Tone Confederate Club at No. 33 The Mall in Waterford on Tuesday 7th March 1848, his place in Irish history was shaped just as powerfully by what happened later that year. As one of the leading figures of the Young Irelanders, he became involved in the 1848 rebellion, culminating in the confrontation at Ballingarry, Thurles, Co. Tipperary, in July.
The Ballingarry rising, though unsuccessful, became one of the defining episodes of the Young Ireland revolt. In its aftermath, Meagher was arrested at Rathcannon, Holycross, Thurles, Co. Tipperary, tried for treason, and sentenced to death, a sentence later commuted to transportation to Van Diemen’s Land*. His exile marked a crucial chapter in his life and secured his place among the most significant Irish nationalist figures of the nineteenth century.
* Van Diemen’s Land was the original European name for the island of Tasmania, Australia, used from its 1642 discovery by Abel Tasman, until renamed in 1856. Settled by the British in 1803, it served as a notorious, harsh penal colony for convicts. It is now a state of Australia known for its rugged landscape.
Earlier that same year, Meagher had unveiled what would later become the national flag of Ireland in his native Waterford. The tricolour flew for eight days and nights before being removed by the then British authorities. Speaking about the flag in April 1848, Meagher said: “The white in the centre signifies a lasting truce between Orange and Green and I trust that beneath its folds the hands of Irish Protestants and Irish Catholics may be clasped in generous and heroic brotherhood.”
The tricolour was adopted as the flag of the Irish Free State in 1922 and formally confirmed as the national flag in the 1937 Constitution.
This weekend’s Thomas Francis Meagher 178th Anniversary Tricolour Celebration will see a three-day festival of talks and events take place in Waterford city. Organisers say the festival offers an opportunity not only to reflect on the proud history of the flag, but also to consider Meagher’s wider legacy as a revolutionary, a political exile, and a symbol of Irish resilience.
Sadly, our local Thurles Tourist Office promoters have seen fit to ignore this same 178th Anniversary Tricolour Celebration. Same seem to be keeping themselves busy promoting Facebook posts about local children’s and men’s clothing shops, local nail bars, pubs, cafés, Easter camps, college open days, and Mother’s Day; clearly the kind of world-famous attractions that have international tourists booking flights as we speak. After all nothing says ‘must-visit destination’ quite like a last-minute Easter camp and a half-price manicure. Seriously, while all these Thurles advertised businesses are unquestionably among the very best in their field, same can hardly be seen as unique selling points (USP’s), as far as foreign tourism attractions are concerned, and therefore are about as useful as an ashtray on a motorcycle.
The commemorative weekend opens this evening with the Thomas Francis Meagher Fife and Drum Band performing at the Granville Hotel on Meagher Quay.
Chairperson of the organising committee, Mr Éamonn McEneaney, said the weekend will feature many highlights, including the Friday evening walking tour of the city, four guest speakers at the Medieval Museum on Saturday morning, a gala dinner on Saturday night, and the military parade, wreath-laying ceremony and raising of the flag on Sunday morning.
Ratepayers’ Cultural Safety Briefing for the Maryland USA Mission (St Patrick’s Weekend Edition).
Tipperary ratepayers warmly welcome news of the proposed Maryland excursion by the CEO of Tipperary County Council, Ms Sinead Carr, along with the Cathaoirleach, Cllr Mr John Carroll and Mr Anthony Fitzgerald (Head of Enterprise and Economic Development and Tourism), latter a brave initiative in international relations, and an even braver initiative in free expensing, courtesy of Tipperary taxpayers.
However, before anyone is released into the wilds of a round of St Patrick’s weekend receptions, it is essential the travelling party completes the Maryland Compulsory Heritage Module, because nothing says “strategic engagement in quantum technologies” like being caught flat-footed on a 19th-century poem in front of a room of people who can quote it at you.
Pic L-R:Barbara Frietchie, & poet John Greenleaf Whittier.
Module 1:Barbara Frietchie (1766 – 1862), [Fritchie, Fritchie-ish, depending on who’s correcting you]. All delegates must demonstrate a working knowledge of the famous Frederick legend in which an elderly woman allegedly waves the Union flag, while Stonewall Jackson passes through, and he, like a well-trained character in a civic morale story, obligingly delivers the appropriate line on cue. Warning, this is not optional. In Maryland, this is basically local scripture, and you will be judged accordingly.
Module 2: Stonewall Jackson, not just a beard, a brand. You don’t have to agree with the legend, but you must be able to nod thoughtfully, while someone says “Of course you know the story…” and you respond like a person who has absolutely not spent the flight learning it from a laminated handout.
Module 3: Frederick’s “Shared Heritage”. Delegates are reminded that Frederick’s history has more edge than a brochure. For example, your hosts may be vaguely aware of the 1781 treason case in Frederick, (Mr Caroll please note), involving British loyalists, including Mr John Caspar Fritchie (Barbara’s father-in-law), convicted in a plot involving British prisoners and a rendezvous with Cornwallis in Virginia, resulting in their nasty executions two months later. This is the part of “people-to-people ties” that rarely makes the PowerPoint, but it does wonders for small talk, if the canapés are slow coming out of the kitchen.
Assessment: A short oral exam may occur at any point, possibly mid-toast, possibly in front of cameras. Passing grade requires:
Correct pronunciation of “Frietchie/Fritchie” without looking panicked.
Ability to smile as if you’ve always loved American Civil War folklore.
The restraint not to say “Sure we’ve our own rebels at home”(referring to ‘People Before Profit’ and ‘Sinn Féin’), unless you enjoy diplomatic incidents.
Anyway, thank God, we are getting some return on our Property Taxes and it’s so comforting, because for a moment there I worried our money was being used efficiently. Now, with the bar so low (it’s basically underground), yet we are still managing to trip over it. Absolutely, nothing says ‘value for money’ like spotting that single working streetlight and the knowing that the Thurles potholes are really just a normal street feature.
Finally, ratepayers would like to reassure this delegation, that if you accidentally confuse Barbara Frietchie with any other historic flag-waver, don’t worry, the room will correct you instantly, with great enthusiasm, at full volume, and for free.
Safe travels. Spend wisely. Reports of any major successes in tourism, business, of course will be required. Oh and for the love of God, do your homework.
Now, to add some educational context; read the poem by John Greenleaf Whittier (1807 – 1892) latter published in October 1863.
Barbara Frietchie.
Up from the meadows rich with corn, clear in the cool September morn, The clustered spires of Frederick stand green-walled by the hills of Maryland. Round about them orchards sweep apple and peach-tree fruited deep, Fair as a garden of the Lord to the eyes of the famished rebel horde, On that pleasant morn of the early fall when Lee marched over the mountain wall, Over the mountains winding down, Horse and foot, into Frederick town. Forty flags with their silver stars, forty flags with their crimson bars, Flapped in the morning wind, the sun of noon looked down, and saw not one. Up rose old Barbara Frietchie then, bowed with her fourscore years and ten; Bravest of all in Frederick town, she took up the flag the men hauled down; In her attic window the staff she set to show that one heart was loyal yet. Up the street came the rebel tread, Stonewall Jackson riding ahead. Under his slouched hat left and right he glanced: the old flag met his sight. “Halt!”, the dust-brown ranks stood fast, “Fire!”, out blazed the rifle-blast. It shivered the window, pane and sash, it rent the banner with seam and gash. Quick, as it fell, from the broken staff, Dame Barbara snatched the silken scarf; She leaned far out on the window-sill, and shook it forth with a royal will. “Shoot, if you must, this old grey head, but spare your country’s flag,” she said. A shade of sadness, a blush of shame, over the face of the leader came. The nobler nature within him stirred, to life at that woman’s deed and word. “Who touches a hair of yon grey head dies like a dog! March on!” he said. All day long through Frederick street, sounded the tread of marching feet, All day long that free flag tossed over the heads of the rebel host. Ever its torn folds rose and fell, on the loyal winds that loved it well, And through the hill-gaps sunset light shone over it with a warm good-night. Barbara Frietchie’s work is o’er, and the Rebel rides on his raids no more. Honour to her, and let a tear fall, for her sake, on Stonewall’s bier. Over Barbara Frietchie’s grave, flag of Freedom and Union, wave, Peace and order and beauty draw round thy symbol of light and law; And ever the stars above look down on thy stars below in Frederick town! End
Dáil Dining – Soup Up 50c, – Calamari Up €1.50, – Wine Heroically Holds the Line.
TDs and Senators have been hit with fresh price increases in the Dáil bar and Members’ restaurant, with higher charges for food introduced in November 2025, while the price of wine, in a brave display of stability, remained unchanged.
According to records released under FOI, the cost of a glass of the Oireachtas Merlot or Sauvignon Blanc is still €6.60, and the €25 bottle price (€60 in the Cashel Palace) also remains in place, proving that in uncertain times, some pillars of national life must not be disturbed.
Meanwhile, the food menu has not been so fortunate: Members’ Restaurant: Tough Choices, like whether to get Dessert and Soup. At lunchtime, soup is now €5.50, up from €5. On the afternoon menu: Deep fried Calamari (with Lemon and Garlic Aioli Rose – a Dip that is great with Chips), from €8 to €9.50. A prime beef burger has increased from €12 to €13.80. [Surprising increase move, what with all this cheap South American beef coming into Éire]. Desserts were repriced to €5.80, up from €5.00, offering options including, Mixed Berry Crumble, Strawberry Cheesecake,assorted Ice Cream, or Fresh Fruit Salad“for the health conscious you understand”.
Dail Bar.
A Soup, Main Course and Dessert now comes in at just over €25, roughly €3 above last year’s prices, but still comfortably below what most people might expect to pay for an equivalent three-course meal in nearby rural Tipperary or indeed in Dublin 2.
In the evening: A Chargrilled Sirloin or Rib-Eye Steak with Fries remains €20.50; this follows a €2.50 increase late last year. Grilled Lamb Cutlets (côtelettes d’agneau grillées) come in at €16 having been replaced by pan-roasted lamb rump (often called chump) at €18.50, (latter a tender, flavorful, and relatively inexpensive cut, that combines the succulence of roasting with the crispy, caramelized crust of pan-searing).
Members’ Bar: Modest Increases, with a few “Steep” surprises.
Evening menu increases included: Gourmet Beef Burger: €12 → €15 [again surprising increase, what with friends in Bord Bia, the Irish Food Board and Dawn Meats] House Chicken Caesar Salad: Possibly imported from the Netherlands, the UK, Brazil, or Thailand, €9 → €11.50. (Tough enough when one can buy a whole Chicken cooked and still hot in Dunnes Stores for €6.75).
Nevertheless, the ambience of the dining area remains reassuringly consistent: muted tones, soft seating, and that steady confidence of a place that rarely needs to check the prices on the street outside. It’s the kind of place where the calamari is deep-fried, the questions are lightly grilled, and accountability is strictly off-menu, while the décor continues to project polished wood, clean lines, and an overall feeling that someone else is picking up the Tab, emotionally, if not financially. In fact the room does what it says on the tin, while remaining dignified, understated and quietly insulated from the chaos of lunch with everyone beyond the M50 and the non-subsidised majority.
Thurles Aldi launches exciting new winter attraction; “Aldi-on-Sea”.
Delighted to see the Thurles Aldi carpark has once again been transformed into a seasonal water feature. Since 2023, it’s become a reliable annual tradition: you arrive for milk and end up needing a canoe.
And no, Storm Chandra had nothing to do with it; Tipperary for the most part escaped the major flooding experienced on the east coast. (But maybe Aldi Ltd, could apply for humanitarian emergency aid funding which was limited to €5,000 and now increased up to €100,000, because Co. Councils down the years successfully failed to maintain our clogged river channels, thus reducing water flow and capacity).
Sunlit and glass-still; Thurles’ Aldi “water feature” waits, like a love letter, for pintail ducks, whooper swans, and even the odd escaped feral mink.
A few helpful customer updates:
Trolleys now come with a complimentary reflection for your Instagram.
Parking bays are “first come, first served” and float-tested.
Shoppers are advised to wear wellies, or at least bring a lifebuoy.
All jokes aside: this happens every winter. It’s not a “once-off”, it’s a recurring problem that needs a proper fix. People shouldn’t have to dodge puddles the size of Liberty Square, in an effort to purchase a loaf of bread.
So, any chance we could upgrade from ‘Seasonal Lagoon‘ to ‘Normal Carpark‘ before winter 2027?
Seriously, following my complaints sent initiallyto Aldi Stores Ltd, I discovered an email waiting on my computer this morning.Same Read:-
Hi George, (Yes, we’re practically pen pals at this stage). Thanks so much for your patience. I can confirm the Area Manager has advised that the work for the car park had to wait for adjacent work to be completed first, organised via the local council. This was completed prior to the festive break. (Xmas 2026) They have confirmed that as a result, the work on the car park to fix appropriate drainage systems is scheduled to be completed by the end of February, (Which February remains unclear). If there is anything else we can assist you with, please don’t hesitate to reach back out. Thanks again for reaching out to us. Best wishes, …………
My reply: Madam: This flooding has been a recurring winter issue since at least 2023. It is particularly difficult to understand the continued problem at the main entrance area where the public drains are almost one metre lower than the Aldi site level itself. With that level difference at the point of outfall, it raises an obvious question as to why a lasting drainage solution was not implemented earlier, rather than allowing the same disruption to customers repeat itself year after year.
Your reply now begs the question, has your anonymous ‘Area Manager’ ever visited Aldi Thurles, since at least 2023 and have staff not repeatedly reported the issue year after year? Has this problem in Thurles not been reflected in Aldi Thurles branch profits? I find the explanation by your area manager both condescending and disappointing. Yours sincerely…………
Obviously Municipal District Officials and local elected Councillors don’t shop there, although Aldi are the only stockists of Ice Cream in Thurles Town, which containing no risky additives, less water and skim milk powder.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.AcceptRead More
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Privacy Overview
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
Recent Comments