Archives

Tipperary Hospital Apologise For Care Breach Leading To Mother & Baby Death.

Tipperary University Hospital apologises for lack of care which led to death of mother and baby

South Tipperary University Hospital, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary has apologised to the family of a young mother for their shortcomings in care, which led to her death and that of her unborn baby.

Ms Caroline Kavanagh was 22 weeks pregnant with her second child, a baby boy, when she first presented at South Tipperary University Hospital’s, Clonmel, emergency department complaining of chest pain.

South Tipperary University Hospital, Clonmel, Co. Tipperary.

Acting counsel for the family, Dr John O’Mahony SC, instructed by solicitor Mr Ciaran O’Keeffe, informed the High Court that the pregnant 37-year old woman was misdiagnosed and her heart symptoms were not identified or indeed addressed, before she had been discharged to her Kilmallock, Co Limerick, place of residence. The young mother was found, five days later, unresponsive by her mother, and sadly later was pronounced dead. The male baby she was carrying at the time sadly also died with his mother.

In an effort to obtain justice, this case had resulted in a 10-year long battle by the family, in the High Court; taken against the HSE over her death, which had occurred on February 11th, 2015.

Interim hospital manager, Ms Ailish Delaney, expressed the establishments profound sympathy and condolences, to Mrs Kavanagh Snr, on the loss of her daughter Caroline and her unborn child.

With a breach of duty admitted by the HSE a statement was read: “The management and staff of the hospital apologise sincerely for the shortcomings in the care which was provided to Caroline and which led to her tragic death. The hospital wishes to acknowledge the heartache and distress suffered by her family because of her premature passing and to express our sincere sympathy and regret.”

During the proceedings, it was claimed that the correct diagnosis of acute heart attack was not made and Ms Kavanagh was not offered appropriate cardiac care when she attended the hospital on February 6th, 2015, resulting in her ultimately death from a heart attack on February 11th, 2015.

It was claimed substandard care had been provided to Ms Kavanagh in failing to provide an echocardiogram. She had been started on cardioprotective medication on her admission to hospital, however same was halted on her discharge.

Presiding Judge, Mr Justice Paul Coffey, extended his deepest sympathy to the extended Kavanagh family.

Emeis Ireland Nursing Homes Issue Apology After RTÉ Investigations.

Emeis Ireland, formerly known as Orpea who operate 27 nursing homes across Ireland and who were featured at the centre of a programme initiated by “RTÉ Investigates”, has issued an apology to both residents and their families.

Emeis Ireland, who first entering the Irish market in 2022; following last night’s undercover investigations by RTE at The Residence Portlaoise, and at Beneavin Manor in Glasnevin, appeared to demonstrated that their chain’s brand, placed profit as their most paramount consideration.

Beneavin House Residential Care Home, located in Glasnevin, Dublin.

An Taoiseach Mr Micheál Martin today expressed grave concern regarding the investigation’s findings and no doubt an Tanaiste Mr Simon Harris will express similar concerns. But will Emeis Ireland be prosecuted for their failure to grant respect and dignity to elderly residents? Will those who were charged with minding both their nursing shops be allowed to continue in their supervisory rolls?

To the majority of those who viewed last night’s programme, RTE’s discovery’s were glimpsed as repulsive, holly unjustifiable, completely unacceptable and enormously distressing, while raising deep concern as to the well-being, the dignity and daily safety of elderly residents in other facilities run by Emeis Ireland.

The usual public relations (PR) machinery was quickly rolled out, once Emeis Ireland realised the game was up. Phrases emanated from their head office, like warmth from a fireplace:-
We will not tolerate any individual or systemic neglect, nor any practices that compromise resident safety, rights, or dignity.”
“All concerns will be promptly investigated, reported to the appropriate regulatory authorities, and followed up with individualised safeguarding plans and strengthened oversight to mitigate the risk of recurrence”
Assistance programmes for residents, families, and staff are being established in response to the serious issues identified,” – the usual horse feathers and empty prattle trotted out in an inconsequential way, by similar large companies on this island of Ireland today.

This situation arises after staff at the bottom of the pay scale, in two Emeis Ireland nursing homes were seen to have left residents dressed in inappropriate incontinence wear, same unchanged for hours, due to a shortage of bed linen. We watched in horror as two frustrated staff roughly manhandled a protesting dementia patient, with no apparent oversight by management. Cutbacks in relation to medical supplies and failure to provide necessary staff required, added to the poor clinical practices carried out across both nursing homes.

While staff members at the Emeis operated nursing homes had made protected disclosures to the Health Information and Equality Authority (HIQA), it had taken 17 weeks for follow-up inspections to be carried out, the programme reported.

HIQA confirmed today that it now carrying out a review of all nursing homes operated by the Emeis Ireland group, following the multiple care failings and obvious neglect of vulnerable older residents at the two nursing homes, documented by ‘RTÉ Investigates’.

So called responsible persons within the Irish health service at the start of the Covid-19 pandemic (coronavirus pandemic) which arrived into Ireland first in February 2020, discovered that Nursing Homes had no personal protective equipment (PPE) available to staff. This error greatly contributed to 6,066 deaths (17%) occurring in same nursing homes, (we won’t mention the 2,188 deaths (6.3%) occurring in hospices), which should have raised a red flag with regard to the activities being carried out in these same establishments run solely without dignity and for profit foremost.

The Leas Cross Nursing Home scandal erupted in Ireland when the nursing home, located near Swords in Dublin, was closed several weeks after a 2005 Prime Time television report revealed sub-standard living conditions there. Yet, some 20 years on we have learned nothing. Leas Cross should have been a wake-up cry and should have sparked real change as to how we, going forward, should be supporting and caring for older people.
Both government and opposition appear to spend their three day week in Dáil Éireann discussing the state of Israel and Gaza, while issues at home break up into small parts as the result of impact and decay

Our heads of government, continue to delude themselves into believing that they are powerful world leader. Sadly, the taxpayer, the government and the opposition can now add this Emeis Ireland nursing home ludicrous and humiliating fiasco to their long list of failures here in Ireland carried out under their watch.

I refer of course to:
The €808,000 Dáil printer scandal, where a printer was purchased but could not fit into the print room, leading to over €230,000 in modifications;
The €725 million RTÉ bailout;
The Office of Public Works (OPW) Government Buildings security hut at a final cost of €1.43 million;
The National Children’s Hospital overrun, which has now surpassed €2.5 billion;
The €22 million spent on covid ventilators, that never worked, with another €50,000 spent on storing them;
The €2.5 billion paid out in medical compensation over ten years, by the Health Service Executive;
The OPW Leinster House bike shed costing €336,000;
The OPW Iveagh House refurbishment costing €825,000;
The National Transport Authority spending on Metro North, (in the region of €300 million) with nothing built;
The OPW wall at the Workplace Relations Commission’s Dublin headquarters, which escalated from an initial estimate of €200,000 to over €490,000;
The 120 electric buses, costing €80.4 million that sat idle for a year and a half in Dublin, due to the lack of charging infrastructure;
The €6.7 million spent by the Arts Council on an Information Technology system, that has never delivered;
The National Gallery scanner, purchased at €120,000, but never used because no suitable room was found;
The failure to protect pedestrians who choose to walk the streets of our Capital City during daylight hours.
The review into the use of unapproved implantable springs in spinal surgery at Temple Street, Children’s Hospital.
The recent issues regarding children’s hip developmental dysplasia at Temple Street, Children’s Hospital and elsewhere.

“Quis custodes ipsos custodiat?” – Translated from the Latin – “Who shall keep the keepers themselves?”

.

Allergy Alert Notification – Fresh Today 4 Chocolate Croissants.

Food Safety Authority of Ireland warn of undeclared egg and hazelnut in certain packages of Fresh Today 4 Chocolate Croissants.

Alert Summary dated Wednesday, June 4th 2025.

Allergy Alert Notification: 2025.A21.
Allergens: Egg, Hazelnut.
Product Identification: Fresh Today frozen 4 Chocolate Croissants.
Batch Code: All best before dates where egg and hazelnut are not declared on the label
.

Message: Fresh Today is recalling certain packages of Fresh Today frozen 4 Chocolate Croissants as they contain egg and hazelnut which are not declared on the product label.
This may make the affected packages unsafe for consumers who are allergic to or intolerant of egg and hazelnut, therefore, these consumers should not eat implicated packages.

FSAI Recall Builin Blasta Dressings – Presence Of Lactic Acid Bacteria.

Recall of specific batches of Builin Blasta dressings due to the presence of lactic
acid bacteria which may cause spoilage.

Alert Summary dated Wednesday, June 4th 2025.

Category 1: For Action.
Alert Notification: 2025.25.
Product Identification: Please see to table below.
Batch Code: Please see to table below.

Message: Builín Blasta Teo is recalling the below batches of specific Builín Blasta dressings, due to the presence of lactic acid bacteria, which may cause spoilage.
Point-of-sale recall notices will be displayed in stores.

Product name.Pack size.Batch numbers.Use by dates.
Builín Blasta Red Onion & Tomato Relish.220g844, 942 and 100911/10/2025, 30/01/2026 and 09/04/2026
Builín Blasta Caesar Dressing.245g831 and 97302/07/2025 and 16/12/2025
Builín Blasta Smoked Onion Salsa.340g963, 982, 986 and 102218/02/2026, 13/03/2026, 19/03/2026 and 24/04/2026

Action Required: Manufacturers, wholesalers, distributors, caterers & retailers:
Retailers: Same are requested to remove the implicated batches from sale and display recall notices at point-of-sale.
Wholesalers/Distributors: Same are requested to contact their affected customers and recall the implicated batches and provide a point-of-sale recall notice to their retail customers.
Consumers: Same are advised not to eat the implicated batches.

FSAI Recall Happy Pear Lovely Basil Pesto – Listeria monocytogenes.

Food Safety Authority of Ireland recall a batch of The Happy
Pear Lovely Basil Pesto, due to the presence of Listeria monocytogenes.

Alert Summary dated Monday, June 2nd 2025.

Category 1: For Action
Alert Notification: 2025.24
Product Identification: The Happy Pear Lovely Basil Pesto 135g
Batch Code: 5149; Use By: 10/07/2025

Message: The Happy Pear are recalling the above batch of The Happy Pear Lovely Basil Pesto due to the presence of Listeria monocytogenes.

Nature Of Danger: Symptoms of Listeria monocytogenes infection can include mild flu-like symptoms, or gastrointestinal symptoms such as nausea, vomiting and diarrhoea. In rare cases, the infection can be more severe, causing serious complications. Some people are more vulnerable to Listeria monocytogenes infections, including pregnant women, babies, and people with weakened immune systems, including the elderly. The incubation period (time between initial infection and first symptoms appearing) is on average 3 weeks but can range between 3 and 70 days.

Action Required: Manufacturers, wholesalers, distributors, caterers & retailers:

Retailers: Same are requested to remove the implicated batches from sale and display recall notices at point-of-sale.
Wholesalers/Distributors: Same are requested to contact their affected customers and recall the implicated batches and provide a point-of-sale recall notice to their retailer customers.
Caterers: Same should not use the implicated batches.
Consumers: Consumers are advised not to eat the implicated batch.