The European Union has won an important legal battle against Kerry Group over smoke flavourings used in everyday foods, including ham, bacon, crisps and other processed products.
But behind this ruling lies a much bigger question; Are we genuinely making our food safer, or could removing one potential danger simply introduce another?
The EU’s decision followed scientific assessments by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), which raised concerns about genotoxicity [Latter the ability of certain substances to damage our DNA]. Such damage can potentially contribute to cancer and other serious health problems. This is not something we should dismiss lightly. However, it is equally important to understand that identifying a potential health hazard is not the same as proving that eating a particular food will cause cancer.
Why The Eu’s Decision Makes Sense For years, the food industry has relied on additives to improve flavour, appearance, consistency and shelf appeal. Consumers understandably expect that ingredients permitted in their food have been thoroughly assessed for safety. Where credible scientific evidence raises concerns about DNA damage, regulators have a responsibility to act. The EU’s position is that manufacturers must provide sufficient evidence that their ingredients are safe, rather than requiring authorities to prove actual harm has already occurred. That is a sensible principle of public health protection. Prevention is better than waiting for evidence of avoidable illness.
But Could The Alternative Be Worse? Kerry Group raised an interesting argument during its legal challenge. Modern smoke flavourings are produced by processing smoke and removing some undesirable contaminants. The company argued that these flavourings could be safer than traditional smoking methods. Traditional smoking can expose food to potentially harmful compounds, including polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), some of which are carcinogenic. If manufacturers respond to the EU decision by returning to less controlled smoking processes, could consumers now end up exposed to greater risks? That possibility deserves proper scientific investigation, even though the court found that Kerry had not demonstrated that such a shift would occur. Replacing one ingredient with another is not automatically a health improvement.
The Bigger Health Issue We Should Not Ignore There is another important consideration. The World Health Organisation has classified processed meat as carcinogenic to humans, based on convincing evidence linking its consumption to colorectal cancer. This includes products such as bacon, ham and sausages. Removing certain smoke flavourings may reduce one source of potential exposure, but it does not suddenly make processed meat a healthy food. Nor does a product become nutritious simply because it is described as natural, traditionally smoked or free from artificial flavourings. The overall nutritional quality of what we eat matters far more than any single marketing claim.
What Should Happen Next? Food producers should use this transition as an opportunity to develop genuinely safer products, rather than simply searching for another chemical or processing method that recreates the same flavour. Regulators, meanwhile, must ensure replacement ingredients are properly assessed and that alternative manufacturing methods do not create additional health risks. Consumers deserve clearer food labelling, transparency about additives and independent scientific evidence. The EU has allowed a phased withdrawal, with the relevant deadline for meat, fish and cheese products extending to July 2029. Other food categories, including crisps, had an earlier July 2026 deadline. That provides an opportunity for responsible reformulation.
My Conclusion I believe the EU is right to take potential DNA-damaging substances seriously. However, good public health policy should be judged not only by what it removes from our food, but also by what replaces it. The goal must be measurable improvements in food safety, not merely a change in ingredients or production methods. This case also reminds us that the most important health question is often overlooked amid arguments over individual additives; Should we be eating so much highly processed food in the first place? Ultimately, the real victory will come when food manufacturers, scientists and regulators work together to produce food that is not only appealing and commercially successful, but demonstrably safer and healthier for consumers.
Food safety should never be a choice between protecting public health and protecting industry. Good science and responsible innovation should serve both.
The growing use of LED street lights, floodlights and security lighting is raising serious concerns about the impact of artificial light on bats, migratory birds, insects and the wider natural environment. Recent court proceedings have highlighted why these concerns cannot simply be ignored.
Modern LED lighting is widely promoted as environmentally friendly because it consumes less electricity, reduces carbon emissions and lowers maintenance costs. However, an important question is increasingly being asked; Are we saving energy at the expense of our wildlife?
Scientific research confirms that artificial light at night can interfere with the natural behaviour of wildlife, disrupting feeding, migration, reproduction and essential biological rhythms. For thousands of years, wildlife has depended upon the natural cycle of daylight and darkness. Today, that delicate balance is increasingly disturbed by powerful artificial lighting.
Back in August 2024 aspeciesofPipistrelles Batcaused similar delays in the erection of a €3.4 million project in Cathedral Street, Thurles.The work has since been completed.
Bats Are Particularly Vulnerable. Ireland’s bats are legally protected, yet many are highly sensitive to artificial illumination. Bats depend upon dark hedgerows, rivers, woodlands and countryside corridors to travel between their roosts and feeding grounds. Bright street lights can discourage certain bat species from using established routes, effectively creating barriers across otherwise suitable habitats. Lighting near roosting sites can delay bats emerging to feed, reducing opportunities to catch insects during the important hours after sunset. Although some bat species feed around street lights, others actively avoid them. Consequently, installing additional lighting may benefit a few species while seriously disadvantaging others.
Migratory Birds Also Face Serious Risks. Artificial lighting can disorient birds migrating at night, drawing them away from established routes and increasing the risk of exhaustion and collisions. Floodlighting near wetlands and feeding grounds can also discourage protected birds from using habitats essential to their survival. This is especially concerning where conservation measures are intended to restore declining bird populations.
Insects. Insects, meanwhile, are attracted to artificial lights, which can interfere with their feeding, reproduction and pollination activities. The consequences extend throughout the food chain.
Hundreds of roosting Pied Wagtails congregate nightly all year round, unnoticed in Liberty Square, Thurles, Co. Tipperary.
An Important Irish High Court Decision In May 2024, the Irish High Court found in favour of environmental organisation Dark Sky Roscommon in a challenge concerning planning permission for 21 floodlights at Tarmon National School, County Roscommon. The case concerned potential effects on the nearby Bellanagare Bog Special Protection Area, associated with the protected Greenland white-fronted goose. The Court found that An Bord Pleanála had failed to properly address reasonable scientific concerns regarding the development’s possible impact on the conservation objectives of the protected area, including the potential return of the geese. The ruling demonstrated that planning authorities must take potential ecological impacts seriously and comply with European environmental assessment requirements. Importantly, this was not a general court ban on LED lighting, nor was it a confirmed order permanently switching off the installed floodlights. Nevertheless, it provides a significant legal warning against overlooking wildlife protection when approving lighting developments.
Why This Matters in County Tipperary This issue has direct relevance to Tipperary. Tipperary County Council is undertaking a substantial programme of converting public street lights to LED technology. According to its 2025 Climate Action Progress Report, the Council maintains approximately 19,000 public lights, with more than 10,000 converted to LED by September 2025. Further upgrades were expected during 2026. Energy efficiency and cost savings are important public objectives. However, the ecological consequences must also be considered. Tipperary contains extensive rivers, hedgerows, woodlands, wetlands and countryside habitats supporting protected wildlife. The River Suir and its associated habitats are particularly important examples of environments where inappropriate lighting could affect wildlife movement and feeding. Significantly, Tipperary County Council’s own Public Lighting Policy, adopted in December 2022, recognises the need for special consideration of lighting near bat roosts, dark-sky areas and environmentally sensitive locations. The question is whether these safeguards are being consistently implemented as LED lighting expands.
Cloughjordan, Co. Tipperary Shows Another Way. There is encouraging news from Tipperary itself. In April 2026, press reported that Cloughjordan Ecovillage had introduced an innovative wildlife-sensitive lighting scheme. Ecological surveys recorded eight of Ireland’s nine established bat species foraging in the ecovillage, along with an impressive diversity of moths. The community responded with carefully directed, warm-coloured, dimmable LED lighting, designed to preserve darkness while allowing residents to move safely at night. Representatives of Tipperary County Council and Bat Conservation Ireland welcomed the initiative. Cloughjordan demonstrates that public safety, modern lighting and biodiversity protection need not be mutually exclusive.
Time for a Countywide Approach? Surely it is reasonable to ask that all new and replacement public lighting in Tipperary be assessed for potential ecological impacts, particularly near rivers, hedgerows, mature trees, bat roosts and protected habitats.
Practical measures could include: Using warmer-coloured, lower-intensity lighting where appropriate. Directing illumination downwards and preventing unnecessary light spill. Dimming or switching off unnecessary lighting during quieter hours, where safe. Maintaining dark wildlife corridors. Undertaking appropriate ecological assessments before installing lighting in sensitive locations.
None of this requires abandoning energy efficiency or compromising essential road safety. It requires thoughtful planning, appropriate technology and recognition that darkness is itself an important natural resource. Sadly in Thurles Co. Tipperary, street lighting remains lit both day and night for the past 4 years.
Protecting the Night Is Protecting Nature Ireland has rightly invested considerable effort in protecting biodiversity, restoring habitats and addressing climate change. Yet these objectives risk being undermined if artificial lighting continues to expand without sufficient regard for nocturnal wildlife. The High Court decision in Roscommon should encourage planning authorities throughout the country to examine the ecological consequences of lighting carefully. Tipperary already has an excellent example of what can be achieved at Cloughjordan Ecovillage. Perhaps the time has come for Tipperary to lead by example, ensuring that the drive towards energy-efficient lighting does not leave our bats, migratory birds and other wildlife struggling to survive in an increasingly illuminated world.
Saving electricity matters. Saving wildlife matters too. We should be capable of doing both.
Registration is now open for the GLOBE Ireland River Ecosystem Campaign 2027. Open to primary and secondary schools nationwide, this hands-on citizen science project gives students the opportunity to investigate the health of their local river while contributing valuable environmental data to a national database.
River Ecosystem Campaign. GLOBE Ireland are inviting schools to take part in this exciting campaign, which will take place during March and April 2027. Participating students will visit their local river ecosystem and explore its health through visual analysis, water sampling, chemical testing, and ecological monitoring. Schools will contribute their findings to the GLOBE international database, helping to build a picture of river health across Ireland. All participating schools will receive free teacher training and support and equipment packs containing everything needed to take part. The campaign will also feature an Expert Webinar, Student Sharing Webinar and GLOBE Ireland Annual Project Competition, which are open to all enrolled schools. Register Your School Places are limited. Registration is open until 27th November 2026 or until all places have been filled. Register to take part here: River Ecosystems Campaign 2027
Learn more. For more information on GLOBE Ireland and their campaigns, email globe@antaisce.org.
GLOBE (Global Learning and Observations to Benefit the Environment) is an international environmental citizen science programme which is active in over 127 countries. In Ireland, the programme is delivered by An Taisce’s Environmental Education Unit (EEU) and is supported and funded by the EPA. The programme delivers citizen science campaigns to hundreds of primary and secondary schools nationwide each year, on themes including climate resilience, air quality, and water quality.
Government must urgently fund nature restoration as 90% of Ireland’s EU-protected habitats are in unfavourable condition, warns Climate Change Advisory Council.
Council criticises lack of dedicated funding for nature restoration in Budget 2027.
Restoring Ireland’s natural environment could deliver almost €33bn in socio-economic benefits by 2050 and strengthen protection against flooding, coastal erosion and other climate impacts.
Professor Yvonne Buckley
Publishing the Biodiversity chapter of its Annual Review 2026 today, the Climate Change Advisory Council has criticised the Government’s failure to commit adequate funding for nature restoration in Budget 2027. No specific allocations for nature restoration have been made through the Infrastructure, Climate and Nature Fund, despite the need to urgently reverse biodiversity loss and prepare Ireland for the growing impacts of climate change.
The latest conservation assessments show that 90% of Ireland’s EU-protected habitat types and 42% of protected species are in unfavourable conservation status, with the majority of protected habitat types continuing to decline.[1] Reversing this decline requires immediate action to tackle the pressures driving biodiversity loss, alongside sustained investment to restore habitats.
The Council says Ireland’s natural habitats must be recognised and invested in as critical natural infrastructure. Healthy wetlands and floodplains help absorb and store excess rainfall, while coastal dunes and saltmarshes provide natural defences against erosion, sea level rise, and storm surges. As these habitats deteriorate, communities lose protections that complement built flood and storm defences.
There is also a strong economic case for investment. Ireland’s draft National Restoration Plan estimates that ecosystem restoration and re-establishment could deliver €32.9 billion in socio-economic benefits between 2024 and 2050, against estimated costs of €5.8 billion. These benefits include reduced flood risks, improved water quality, increased carbon sequestration and healthier ecosystems.
Funding for the National Parks and Wildlife Service has increased in recent years, with €112 million allocated for 2027. While welcoming this investment, Ireland’s investment gap for biodiversity protection and restoration is estimated at €700 million per year and a dedicated, long-term funding programme to deliver the National Restoration Plan is urgently needed.
The Council is calling for multi-annual funding commitments, greater investment in nature-based measures and financial supports for farmers and landowners to restore and manage habitats. With more ecologists and conservation specialists currently needed to support existing work, restoration efforts would also support further skilled employment creation in rural Ireland.
Professor Yvonne Buckley, Member of the Climate Change Advisory Council, said: “Nine in ten of Ireland’s EU-protected habitat types are in unfavourable condition. We know how serious the problem is, yet we still haven’t committed the long-term funding needed to turn things around. There is a clear business case for this investment into biodiversity and nature restoration efforts. Without functioning and restored ecosystems, Ireland will suffer economically, ecologically and socially. The increase in funding for the National Parks and Wildlife Service is welcome but it is not enough. While we also welcome the commitment of €715 million to the Office for Public Works for flood-risk management between 2026 and 2030, we need to see the same level of ambition when it comes to restoring the wetlands, peatlands and coastal habitats that help protect communities across Ireland. Nature is critical infrastructure that helps us to achieve our climate mitigation and adaptation targets with many co-benefits. It is not an optional extra.”
Local Authority Integration Team (LAIT) Monthly Drop Clinic.
Ms Maura Barrett Reports From Cashel Library, Co. Tipperary.
The Local Authority Integration Team (LAIT) Monthly Drop Clinic will take place in Cashel Library. on tomorrow Wednesday November 4th from 9:30am–12:00 noon.
LAIT offers guidance on employment, English classes, health, social welfare, community activities, CV support and volunteer organisations
Contact Cashel Library Tel: 062-63825.
You canlocate Cashel Library building, situated on Friar Street, Lady’s Well, Cashel, Co. Tipperary, HERE. [Eircode E25 K798].
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.AcceptRead More
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Privacy Overview
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
Recent Comments