The Cormack Brothers – Guilty Or Innocent Republished

It happened 150 years ago this year and of the seventeen men publicly executed outside North Tipperary’s County Gaol in Nenagh, between 1842 and 1858, the true story of William and Daniel Cormack is one of the few that still remains fresh in folk memory, not just only here in County Tipperary and on the island of Ireland, but also in the USA, Australia, England and Canada.

I first heard about the Cormack Brothers as a small boy living in Co. Wexford and when I arrived here, to reside in Co.Tipperary in 1975, over the next 23 years, I listened intently to the constant and various arguments and debates, with regard as to their true guilt or innocent.

"Guilty or Innocent?" Reprinted

Then in 1998, a marvelous book, entitled appropriately ‘Guilty or Innocent? by author and Tipperary historian Nancy Murphy, appeared on our book shelves. Now for the first time, lovers of history and Tipperary folklore, had compiled together and easily accessible to them, the full factual details of the Cormack Brothers trial, their execution and their exhumation.

The book was the outcome of years of extensive research, carried out painstakingly by the author, into newspapers, official and private correspondence, the Trant Papers, the Petitions for Reprieve, Parish Registers, Poor Law Rate Books and other land records. The book put together, accurately and for the very first time, the known truth, without bias. Not surprisingly the book was sold out within weeks of its original publication date and up until this week was commanding figures of in excess of €64 to €130 in just secondhand condition.

Now, due to popular demand Relay Books, Tyone, Nenagh, Co.Tipperary have agreed to republished ‘Guilty or Innocent?‘ in a limited edition, to meet the renewed interest in the Cormack Brother’s fate this year, being the 150th anniversary of their death.

The Cormack Brother’s murder trial is too complex to discuss in this blog, but Chapter 18, of this well researched book, examines aspects of the Cormack Brother’s case to be questioned, under the following headings :

Were the members of the Grand Jury correct in sending the Cormack Brothers for trial?
The conduct of the investigation as revealed in the trials;
The conduct of the trials by prosecution, defence and presiding Judge;
The quality of the evidence and consequently whether the second Trial Jury was justified in their verdict;
Were there grounds for appeal, for a case stated by the judge for judgement by the Superior Court, and ultimately for mercy by the Lord Lieutenant?

Finally, and leaving the law aside, has the widespread belief in the Cormack Brother’s innocence been justified? The author quotes the indirect evidence for this and leaves a conclusion to the reader.

Within the last few months, the tiny village of Loughmore,Co.Tipperary, native parish to William and Daniel Cormack, have marked the anniversary of their execution and exhumation, by an impressive and evocative recreation of the 1910 funeral of the brothers exhumed remains. They also staged a play, “The Cormack Brothers”, in the parish centre over seven nights, playing to full houses and standing room only.

The limited republished edition of ‘Guilty or Innocent?‘ in paperback, retails at just €12.90 plus €2.00 for postage and packing.

This book is an excellent read for factual history lovers, especially if you enjoy a story where ‘truth is stranger than fiction.’  Take it from me this book is one hell of good read.


7 comments to The Cormack Brothers – Guilty Or Innocent Republished

  • Mairead Bolger

    Hi I have only just now heard about the Cormack Brothers (on local radio and went on google immediately) and I am totally intrigued, I so want to learn more about these brothers.

    Please let me know if it is possible to acquire a copy of Guilty or Innocent by Nancy Murphy I just have to learn more!!!!!!

    Can’t wait Mairead

  • Contact: Relay Books, Tyone, Nenagh, Co.Tipperary. They may be able to assist at Telephone 067 31734.

  • Katie O.Connell. Knott

    George. I might be wrong. Were the McCormack brothers buried outside Templemore? I can sort of remember the Nuns talking about these brothers and saying they were buried outside Templemore.

  • Hi Katie,
    They were buried in Loughmore village cemetary, just a few miles outside Thurles, (as you travelling North towards Templemore). Regards.

  • Ciara O'Sullivan

    There is currently a film being made about this story. It is being made by Krown Films and is being released for public screenings in February 2015. Check local press for details or if you prefer you can find all the information on Cormack Brothers facebook page or on the film company’s website Dvd’s will be available from the Krown Films website soon. The film was shot on location in Loughmore Co. Tipperary which is the brothers’ final resting place. The film will also be taken on a screening tour of the USA in Summer of 2015.

  • Matthew Costello

    My Great Grandfather Thomas Long from Cloughjordan told my grandmother…he committed the murder, this has been the most famous story in my family for 160 yrs

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>




seven − 2 =

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.