If women are equal before God, why are they still excluded from the Roman Catholic priesthood?
Yesterday, October 17th, a historic gathering of Roman Catholics in Gormanston, Co Meath, brought one of the oldest and most controversial questions in Christianity, back into the spotlight; Why does the Roman Catholic Church continue to exclude women from ordained ministry?
At Ireland’s first National Synodal Assembly of its kind, delegates voted on proposals concerning the future of the Church, including the position of women. On the proposal for continued exploration of women’s ministry, including ordination to the diaconate, 54% voted in favour, 42% highly recommending it and another 12% recommending it. However, 27% opposed the recommendation and 19% wanted further consideration. Interestingly, a separate proposal to establish a national office for women was rejected, with 56% voting against it.
These mixed results demonstrate that the Church is far from united on how women should participate in its future. But surely the deeper question is not simply whether women should be permitted to become deacons. It is whether there is any convincing justification for continuing to exclude them from the priesthood altogether.
Why Does The Church Exclude Women? The Vatican’s traditional argument rests primarily on three claims.
Sedia Stercoraria (The Dung Chair)
First, Jesus chose twelve male apostles. Second, the Church has maintained a male priesthood through centuries of tradition. Third, Catholic theology teaches that a priest represents Christ in a particular sacramental capacity. In 1994, Pope John Paul II declared that the Church had no authority to ordain women as priests and insisted that this teaching was definitive. But should the customs of a male-dominated society two thousand years ago determine the opportunities available to women today? Jesus treated women with remarkable dignity, often challenging the conventions of his time. Women supported his ministry, remained faithful at the Crucifixion and were among the first witnesses to the Resurrection. Mary Magdalene, in particular, occupies an extraordinary place in Christian history. Surely, if women could proclaim the Resurrection, surely we are entitled to ask why they cannot proclaim the Gospel from the altar as ordained priests.
And what about Pope Joan? There is an extraordinary story from medieval Church history that deserves mentioning. For centuries, accounts circulated of a woman known as Pope Joan, who supposedly disguised herself as a man, entered the priesthood and eventually became Pope during the ninth century. According to the legend, her identity was exposed when she unexpectedly gave birth during a religious procession through Rome. Most modern historians regard the story as a legend rather than established historical fact. Nevertheless, an equally remarkable tradition developed around the story. Special chairs (marbleperforated chairs “Sedia Stercoraria” meaning the Dung Chair“), with holes in their seats, associated with papal ceremonies, were supposedly used to establish that a newly elected pope was biologically male. The alleged inspection was even accompanied, according to later accounts, by a declaration confirming the pope’s masculinity. According to the legend, after the scandal involving Pope Joan, every newly elected pope was required to sit on a special chair while a cleric physically checked beneath the seat to establish that he possessed male genitalia. The cleric supposedly announced: “Duos habet et bene pendentes”, (Meaning; “He has two, and they hang well.”) The assembled clergy supposedly would reply, “Deo gratias”, (Meaning; “Thanks be to God.”) Perforated chairs associated with papal ceremonies really did exist. However, there is no reliable evidence that they were used for such examinations. The Pope Joan story therefore cannot be presented as proof that a woman once occupied the papacy. Yet the persistence of the legend is a fascinating reminder of how deeply gender and religious authority have been intertwined throughout Church history.
Illustration of Pope Innocent X having his testicles examined, from Roma Triumphans (1645).
A church sustained by women but governed by men. Across Ireland, generations of women have sustained Catholic life. They have educated children, staffed hospitals, cared for the sick, maintained parish communities, organised charitable activities, supported religious vocations and passed the faith from one generation to the next. Without women, much of the Church’s daily work would simply be impossible. Yet when it comes to the authority to celebrate Mass, administer certain sacraments or become a bishop or pope, women remain excluded.
The Church insists that men and women possess equal dignity. But can an institution convincingly claim equality while permanently reserving its most important ordained offices for men? Supporters of the existing doctrine sincerely argue that this is a matter of faithfulness to Christ rather than discrimination. Others believe that the Church has confused historical tradition with divine instruction and that centuries of exclusively male leadership have helped preserve that interpretation.
Another long-overdue question is whether Roman Catholic priests should be permitted to marry. Celibacy is a Church discipline, not an unchangeable doctrine of the Christian faith. Indeed, married men already serve as priests in some Eastern Catholic Churches in full communion with Rome, and exceptions also exist in the Western Church. If marriage is regarded by the Church as a sacred institution, why should it ordinarily prevent a man from entering the priesthood? Surely a married priest, with the experience of family life, raising children and sharing everyday responsibilities, could bring valuable understanding and compassion to his ministry. Celibacy should remain a respected personal vocation, but why must it be compulsory? At a time when Ireland faces a serious shortage of priests, surely allowing married men to enter the priesthood deserves serious consideration alongside the question of women’s ordination.
The Irish Bishops now have a choice. The recommendations from the Gormanston assembly will go to the Irish Catholic bishops for consideration. The delegates did not vote to introduce women priests, and the recommendation concerning the diaconate does not alter Vatican teaching. Nevertheless, the meeting has reopened an important conversation. At a time when religious practice is declining, congregations are ageing and many parishes face difficulties maintaining sufficient clergy, surely the Catholic Church must seriously consider whether excluding women from ordained ministry serves its spiritual mission.
The Church has changed its practices and developed its understanding of many questions over the centuries. Why, then, must the possibility of women becoming priests remain permanently closed? This should not be about attacking religion or dismissing sincere religious belief. It should be about justice, participation and whether the Church is prepared to listen to the women who have contributed so much to its survival.
The final question is a simple one: If a woman is sufficiently worthy to teach the faith, nurture a Christian community, care for the vulnerable and proclaim the message of Jesus Christ, why is she considered ineligible to stand at the altar as a priest?
Perhaps the greatest challenge facing the Catholic hierarchy is no longer simply persuading people to return to the Church. It is persuading people that the Church itself is prepared to listen, reflect and change.
From Dalkey to the Fields of Flanders: Remembering Fr Willie Doyle and Tipperary’s Forgotten Heroes of Passchendaele.
“Bent double, like old beggars under sacks, Knock-kneed, coughing like hags, we cursed through sludge, Till on the haunting flares we turned our backs, And towards our distant rest began to trudge. Men marched asleep. Many had lost their boots, But limped on, blood-shod. All went lame, all blind; Drunk with fatigue; deaf even to the hoots Of tired, outstripped Five-Nines♦ that dropped behind”.
Above verse is an extract from “Dulce et Decorum Est”, a poem by Wilfred Owen. [Latin poem title is taken from a verse written by the Roman poet Horace: “dulce et decorum est pro patria mori”. English translation means “It is sweet and proper to die for one’s country”.] ♦Five-Nines: Refers to 5.9-inch German explosive and gas artillery shells (15cm calibre) commonly used on the Western Front during World War I.
More than 109 years after his death on the battlefields of Belgium, an extraordinary Irish priest is once again making headlines as the Roman Catholic Church prepares to advance his cause for sainthood in Rome, Italy. But the story of Fr Willie Doyle also provides an opportunity to remember the soldiers and chaplains from Thurles and County Tipperary who lost their lives during one of the bloodiest campaigns of the First World War. Their names, sacrifices and family connections deserve to be remembered.
A Brave Irish Priest from Dalkey Father William Joseph Gabriel Doyle was born on March 3rd, 1873, at Melrose, Dalkey Avenue, County Dublin, the youngest of seven children; parents Hugh Doyle and Christine Byrne. He entered the Society of Jesus in 1891 and was ordained in Dublin in 1907. During the First World War, Fr Doyle volunteered as a military chaplain with the 16th (Irish) Division, providing spiritual comfort and practical assistance to soldiers facing unimaginable suffering. His bravery earned him the Military Cross. On August 16th 1917, during the Battle of Langemarck, part of the wider Passchendaele campaign, Fr Doyle was killed while attempting to assist two wounded protestant officers, while under German shellfire. He was just 44 years old. His body was never recovered. His compassion extended to Catholic and Protestant soldiers alike, making him an enduring symbol of courage that transcended religious divisions.
Thurles and Tipperary’s Forgotten HeroesRemembered. The Battle of Passchendaele, officially the Third Battle of Ypres, raged from July 31st until November 10th 1917. Among those who died during the campaign were men with strong connections to Thurles and surrounding County Tipperary.
James (Jim) Maher – Thurles, Co. Tipperary. Mr James Maher died on August 11th 1917, (5 days previous to Father William Doyle), during the opening weeks of the campaign. In June 2025, saw the remarkable discovery of his wartime letters and medals during a house clearance near Thurles. His grandnephew Mr Denis Kenny helped bring the story to public attention. Remarkably, while James served in the British Army, his sister Josephine was a member of Cumann na mBan, in Thurles [(The Irishwomen’s Council), latter an Irish republican women’s paramilitary organisation founded in Dublin on April 2nd, 1914], , supporting the struggle for Irish independence. Their correspondence reveals how families could remain close despite profoundly different political circumstances.
Lance Corporal John Cooke – Bonlea (Bawnlea), The Commons, Thurles, Co. Tipperary. Born on 5 February 1894, Mr John Cooke emigrated to Canada and enlisted in the Canadian Expeditionary Force. Serving with the 27th Canadian Infantry Battalion, he was killed at Passchendaele on November 6th 1917, aged just 23 years. He has no known grave and is commemorated on the Menin Gate Memorial at Ypres.
Fr Michael Bergin SJ — Fancroft, Roscrea, Co. Tipperary. Born in 1879 at Fancroft near Roscrea, Fr Michael Bergin became a Jesuit priest and served as a military chaplain with Australian soldiers. He had previously served during the Gallipoli campaign. On 11th October 1917, he was killed by German shellfire near an aid post during the fighting at Passchendaele, aged 38. He received the Military Cross posthumously and is buried in Reningelst Churchyard, Belgium. Like Fr Willie Doyle, his ministry was marked by extraordinary courage and devotion to wounded soldiers.
Fr Patrick Looby — Cahir, Co. Tipperary. Born in Cahir in 1889, Fr Patrick Looby studied for the priesthood in Waterford and Paris before his ordination in 1914. Serving as a British Army chaplain attached to the Northumberland Fusiliers, he was killed during the Passchendaele fighting on October 26th 1917, aged just 28years. He is buried in Poelcapelle British Cemetery and commemorated on the Cahir War Memorial.
Private William Quinn — Clogheen, Co. Tipperary. Mr William Quinn, recorded as having come from Clogheen, County Tipperary, served with the 2nd Battalion, Royal Munster Fusiliers. He died on November 10th 1917, aged just 27years, the final day of the Passchendaele campaign. His story reminds us that Tipperary’s wartime losses extended to the very end of this devastating battle.
A Possible Irish Saint. Tomorrow, Sunday, October 18th 2026, an important ceremony will take place at the Cathedral of Christ the King, Mullingar, Co. Westmeath, at 4:00pm. Bishop Tom Deenihan will preside over the formal conclusion of the diocesan investigation into Fr Willie Doyle’s cause for beatification and canonisation. The gathered evidence will subsequently be forwarded to Rome for examination. Although the Church has not yet declared Fr Doyle a saint, this represents a significant milestone in recognising his life and sacrifice.
Their Sacrifice Must Never Be Forgotten From Dalkey, Co Dublin, to Thurles, Roscrea, Cahir, and Clogheen in Co. Tipperary, these stories reveal the human cost of a war fought far from home. These men were not simply names on military memorials. They were sons, brothers, priests, friends and neighbours whose deaths left grieving families and communities across Ireland. Their experiences also remind us of the complexity of Irish history, when men serving in British, Australian and Canadian forces could belong to families deeply involved in Ireland’s struggle for independence. As Fr Willie Doyle’s remarkable story receives renewed recognition, let us also remember the Tipperary men who died in the mud of Flanders. Their courage, suffering and sacrifice form an important part of our shared history. May Fr Willie Doyle and all the fallen soldiers of Passchendaele rest in peace.
Credit cards offer convenience and security, but behind the attractive offers and easy spending, lies a costly financial reality. Are Irish consumers sufficiently protected?
Credit cards are useful for online shopping, emergencies and managing short-term expenses. However, high interest rates, minimum repayments and additional charges can quietly turn everyday purchases into long-term debt.
In Ireland, credit card providers operate under consumer protection rules, but understanding the risks remains essential.
The Minimum Repayment Trap. According to Ireland’s Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC), minimum monthly repayments are generally around 2% – 5% of the outstanding balance. Paying only this amount may keep your account up to date, but interest continues accumulating.The CCPC illustrates that a €1,000 balance at 17% interest, with monthly repayments of €50, takes approximately two years to clear. Increasing repayments to €100 reduces this to around 11 months.
Consumer Tip: Pay your balance in full whenever possible, or substantially more than the minimum.
High Interest and Hidden Charges. The CCPC reports that Irish credit card interest rates can range from approximately 13% to 22.9%. Additional charges may include late payment fees, foreign currency transaction fees and cash withdrawal charges. Ireland also imposes an annual €30 government stamp duty on credit card accounts, collected by card providers on behalf of Revenue.
Consumer Tip: Compare Annual Percentage Rates (APRs), examine fees and avoid withdrawing cash using credit cards.
Rewards That Encourage Overspending. Cashback, loyalty points and promotional offers can encourage spending beyond genuine needs. A reward worth €10 is hardly beneficial if obtaining it requires an unnecessary €500 purchase!
Consumer Tip: Never buy something simply to qualify for rewards. A higher credit limit is not additional income.
The Interest-Free Period Misunderstanding. Many Irish credit cards offer an interest-free period of up to approximately 56 days. However, this generally depends on paying the full amount owed by the deadline. Paying only part of the balance may trigger interest on purchases from their transaction dates.
Consumer Tip: Read promotional terms carefully and arrange automatic repayments.
What Protection Do Irish Consumers Have? Ireland’s strengthened Central Bank Consumer Protection Code 2025, effective from 24th March 2026, places statutory obligations on regulated financial providers to safeguard customers’ interests. These include requirements concerning fair treatment, effective consumer information, responsible product design and support for vulnerable customers. Consumers also have important avenues for redress: CCPC: Independent information, comparison tools and consumer guidance. Financial Services and Pensions Ombudsman (FSPO): Free, independent complaints resolution after raising the issue with the provider. MABS: Free, confidential budgeting and debt advice. Chargeback: Consumers may be able to dispute eligible card transactions through their provider. The Way Forward: Protection Through Awareness Irish regulators have strengthened consumer safeguards, but regulation alone cannot prevent every financial mistake or unsuitable borrowing decision. Greater financial education, transparent pricing, responsible lending and proactive monitoring of harmful financial practices remain important. Credit cards should provide financial flexibility, not financial dependency. The safest approach is simple: borrow only what you can repay, monitor your spending and understand every charge.
Should Irish banks be required to do more to prevent consumers becoming trapped in long-term credit card debt?
Efforts are intensifying to resolve Ireland’s public sector pay dispute following yesterdays (Wednesday’s) nationwide strike involving more than 300,000 workers.
With a second stoppage scheduled for Wednesday, 21st October, attention has turned to whether Government and trade unions can agree a negotiating framework before further disruption occurs. For County Tipperary, the dispute extends well beyond national pay negotiations. It directly affects hospitals, schools, council services, rural communities and the wider local economy.
A possible breakthrough in negotiations The previous public service pay agreement expired in June 2026. Unions insist that restoring workers’ purchasing power must be prioritised, while the Government maintains that any new agreement must be affordable and include consideration of public service reform and productivity. Taoiseach Mr Micheál Martin has expressed willingness to find a resolution, while Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers has indicated that pay can be addressed first in negotiations. The Government has allocated €1.2 billion towards a new agreement, although unions argue that increases must adequately reflect inflation and rising household expenses.
Discussions involving the Workplace Relations Commission could provide a pathway towards formal negotiations, but no agreement has yet been secured.
Healthcare: A particular concern for rural Tipperary. Healthcare disruption is especially significant in a county where many residents travel considerable distances for appointments. Services associated with University Hospital Clonmel, Nenagh Hospital and UHL serviving North Tipperary together with community healthcare facilities operate within a system already facing considerable demand. Nationally, the HSE cancelled routine outpatient appointments, planned procedures, community clinics and non-essential day services during yesterday’s strike. Emergency care, dialysis and urgent cancer treatment continued. For patients travelling from communities such as Borrisokane, Cahir, Cashel and rural west Tipperary, cancelled appointments create additional difficulties involving transport, family support and time away from employment. The impact is particularly relevant to older residents. According to Census 2022, Tipperary had 167,895 residents, including 29,356 people aged 65 or over, representing approximately 17.5% of the county’s population. Reliable healthcare and community support services are therefore of considerable local importance.
Tipperary County Council: Services disrupted The immediate local consequences were evident on yesterday when Tipperary County Council closed its offices, public amenities and public-facing services because of industrial action involving SIPTU, Fórsa and Unite. Residents in Thurles, Clonmel, Nenagh, Roscrea, Tipperary Town and Carrick-on-Suir were among those affected. Routine housing enquiries, local authority administration and access to public facilities were interrupted. Emergency arrangements remained available for urgent roads and housing matters through 0818 06 5003. Further industrial action could produce similar disruption next week, although specific arrangements have yet to be confirmed.
Education: Pressure on families and students Schools and colleges were among the services most visibly affected nationally. For Tipperary families, school closures created childcare difficulties, disrupted working arrangements and placed additional pressure on parents, particularly those commuting from rural communities. Technological University of the Shannon confirmed that its Clonmel and Thurles campuses would retain access to their main buildings, but classes, assessments, workshops and scheduled laboratory activities would not proceed during yesterday’s stoppage. Another strike next Wednesday could create similar challenges for students, teachers, parents and employers.
The wider Tipperary economy There is also an important economic dimension. Public sector employees contribute substantially to local economic activity through spending in shops, supermarkets, cafés and other businesses throughout the county. For workers living outside major towns, increasing fuel, heating, transport and household costs can place particular pressure on disposable income. Pay levels and employment conditions may also influence the recruitment and retention of teachers, nurses, healthcare professionals and local authority staff. These issues deserve attention in rural counties such as Tipperary, where access to essential services can already involve lengthy journeys. Equally, Government must consider the long-term financial sustainability of pay settlements and the resources required to maintain public services.
What happens next? The immediate priority is establishing negotiations that both sides consider acceptable. Union leaders have warned of a prolonged dispute unless meaningful progress is achieved. Meanwhile, Government representatives have reiterated their willingness to engage directly on pay. As of Thursday evening, 15th October, the planned second strike on 21st October has not been called off.
For Tipperary residents, the coming days will be important in determining whether schools, hospitals and council services face renewed disruption.
The Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI) has today published a scientific report outlining food-based dietary guideline recommendations for adolescents aged 9–18 living in Ireland. This is the first scientific report to set out specific food-based dietary recommendations for this age group. Nutritional needs during adolescence can vary considerably, depending not only on age and sex, but also on body size, physical activity and the timing of puberty. Developed by the FSAI Scientific Committee, the recommendations take account of these differences to provide a scientific basis for supporting healthy growth and development during this important stage of life.
Mr Greg Dempsey, (Chief Executive of FSAI), said the recommendations are an important step in ensuring that dietary guidance reflects the particular nutritional needs of adolescents. “This report is the first to set out specific food-based dietary recommendations for adolescents living in Ireland. The dramatic transition from childhood to adulthood requires very high nutrient intakes to ensure that adolescents reach their full potential as adults, both physically, for example in terms of height, and cognitively. These food-based recommendations from our Scientific Committee reflect the most current scientific understanding of nutritional issues affecting this age group. Based on recent dietary surveys, the recommendations align with current adolescent food habits in Ireland and also consider environmental sustainability.”
According to Professor Kevin Cashman, who was Chair of the FSAI Public Health Nutrition Subcommittee when this report was developed, adolescence is a life stage when nutritional requirements are particularly high. “Adolescence is a key developmental window of opportunity for nutrition. During this time, children lay down 40% of their bone mass, protecting them from osteoporosis in later life. In addition, they gain 50% of their adult weight and 20% of their adult height. It is important to note that there is a significant variation in nutritional needs among adolescents, including those of the same age. These differences relate to body size, for example tall versus small; physical activity levels, from sedentary to very active; and maturational timing, such as adolescents who are early versus late developers.”
The food-based recommendations in the scientific report are designed to be flexible and to show how food choices can be adjusted to meet these different nutritional needs. In this way, the food-based dietary guidelines support optimal growth and development across the full spectrum of adolescent requirements.
Key recommendations from the report include:-
Adolescents have high energy requirements: Food requirements can be substantial during adolescence, with 15% of the dietary patterns modelled exceeding 3,000 kilocalories per day.
Food needs to vary between adolescents: Recommendations should take account of age, sex, body size and physical activity, recognising that two adolescents of the same age may have very different nutritional requirements.
Carbohydrate foods (cereals and breads, potatoes, pasta, and rice) are the most important food group for fuelling physical activity (providing calories), with average requirements ranging from 6 to 10 servings and requirements reaching up to 13 servings for some adolescents.
Four to five servings per day from the milk, yogurt and cheese food group fulfil calcium requirements. Four servings per day are recommended for sedentary to low active adolescents, while five servings per day are recommended for moderately active to very active adolescents. However, adolescents with very high calorie requirements (e.g. very physically active) may require more from this group to meet their energy needs.
In general, plant-based dairy replacement foods and beverages are not recommended due to their nutritional composition and the need for addition of calcium and other micronutrients. Where plant-based dairy alternatives are required, a calcium-fortified soya beverage represents the best choice for males, and calcium- and iodine-fortified brands represent the best choice for females.
Protein requirements were easily achieved, despite the reduction in the amounts and frequency of meat consumption. Protein powders, shakes and supplementary drinks were unnecessary to meet protein goals.
Including oily fish once a week is recommended to help improve intake of the omega-3 fatty acids DHA and EPA, which can otherwise be difficult to achieve.
The modelling showed that sugar and saturated fat intakes can be reduced to recommended levels, while healthier choices of foods such as yogurts, breakfast cereals and discretionary foods can help reduce saturated fat, sugar and salt intake.
Adolescents and their caregivers should use nutrition labelling when choosing foods such as breakfast cereals and yogurts, helping them identify options that meet healthier choice criteria.
All adolescents should continue to take a vitamin D food supplement – amount required is dependent on the individual’s age and ethnicity, and the time of year.
All women of childbearing age, including adolescents, who can become pregnant should take a 400 µg folic acid supplement every day.
A minimal intake of foods high in sugar, saturated fat and salt (such as preserves, confectionery, biscuits and crisps) may be included to meet higher energy requirements of some adolescents. This report highlights better choices (lower in fat, sugar and salt) of these discretionary foods.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish.AcceptRead More
Privacy & Cookies Policy
Privacy Overview
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
Recent Comments